George Le Masurier photo
Cumberland mayor to shine light on bullying in local politics, nonprofits
Cumberland Mayor Leslie Baird knows what it’s like to be bullied as an adult woman in the Comox Valley. She entered politics in the early 1990s, when the Village Council table was more the province of men than it is today. And she has sat on enough nonprofit boards to experience dictatorial board chairs and intimidating fellow board members.
So she knows that bullying in local politics and nonprofits has nothing to do with the #metoo era, social media or overreaching political correctness.
And the mayor is determined to shine a spotlight on the problem.
Baird has invited 80 local women, and some men, to a second workshop that will feature local citizens talking about their experiences with bullying in politics, nonprofits and business workplaces. More than 40 women attended her first workshop last spring.
“We’re broadening our perspective this time,” she told Decafnation. “And including a focus on nonprofits and other organizations, not just politics.”
Baird and her committee have assembled a panel that includes professionals to help define bullying, how to recognize it and what to do what it happens.
“One of the goals of this workshop is not just to learn how to defend yourself against bullying, but also how to recognize it when it’s happening to someone else,” she said.
The last time Baird was bullied herself occurred at a Comox Valley Chamber of Commerce meeting, and the perpetrator was a male elected official.
“No one stopped him,” she said. “His behavior changed the whole atmosphere for everyone, made us all uncomfortable. Very negative.”
Baird said people who don’t stop or call out bullying are accessories to the crime. So she hopes the workshop will help people recognize bullying and find the courage to step in when it’s appropriate.
“I know that would be easier for some people to do than others,” she said. “But I think you would feel good that you did something that needed to be done.”
Bullying in nonprofits
According to a 2014 University of Windsor study more than half of Canadians reported at least one act of workplace harassment every week for the previous six months. A 2014 Angus Reid survey found that 43 percent of women have been sexually harassed on the job. And a Great West Life study reported that 71 percent of Canadian employees report concern over their psychological safety at work.
And nonprofits are not immune.
The Canadian online resource for nonprofits, Charity Village, reports that 78 percent of workplace bullies outrank their targets. And that includes donors or board members who threaten or intimidate nonprofit employees.
Board bullying is common and, according to one article on Charity Village, may be “more prevalent in the nonprofit sector than in the business sector.”
Bullying on nonprofit boards comes in five main forms, according to Charity Village: internal board interactions (such as ostracism and peer pressure), board to staff, board self-dealing (such as pressure to deliver inappropriate favors or benefits), sexual harassment and enabling bullying among staff (such as failing to take action, or willful ignorance of bullying at the staff level).
Bullying in politics
Bullying in politics is not a new concept. Men have historically dominated public office and the pioneering women who dared to enter this domain have almost all experienced some form of bullying.
Baird says she has noticed that political culture is slowly evolving, but holding public office is still harder today for women than for men.
“Some men don’t realize they are doing it, because they’ve been doing it for so long,” she said. “If you’ve been bullied for years, it’s hard to get out of that situation.”
Baird said local politics is a prime hotbed for bullying.
“People think they have the right to say anything they want to, especially during election campaigns. It can be very hurtful,” she said.
As a mayor, Baird tries to avoid using her position in a way that intimidates other council members.
“Every councillor has the right to speak uninterrupted and to voice their opinion,” she said. “The mayor’s job is not to argue or criticize another councillor’s thoughts. We get a better product if we all listen to what other people are saying.”
There have been various and serious allegations of bullying against several different trustees on the Union Bay Improvement District for years.
Men also experience bullying, though perhaps not as frequently as women.
Former BC Liberal Party cabinet minister Bill Bennett called Premier Gordon Campbell a bully who was vocally abusive, sometimes reducing caucus members to tears.
“You have almost a battered wife syndrome inside our caucus today,” Bennett was quoted as saying at the time.
Positive outcomes
Bullying in politics or in nonprofits isn’t something that people feel comfortable talking about, according to Baird. Women, for example, just learn to deal with it.
So the Cumberland mayor hopes her workshop can break through that barrier.
“I want to make it (bullying) visible,” she said. “And when it does happen, not to sit back and allow it to continue, that people will stand up and stop it.”
WHAT IS BULLYING AND CYBERBULLYING?
Bullying happens when there is an imbalance of power; where someone purposely and repeatedly says or does hurtful things to someone else. Bullying can occur one on one or in a group(s) of people. There are many different forms of bullying:
— Physical bullying (using your body or objects to cause harm): includes hitting, punching, kicking, spitting or breaking someone else’s belongings.
— Verbal bullying (using words to hurt someone): includes name calling, put-downs, threats and teasing.
— Social bullying (using your friends and relationships to hurt someone): includes spreading rumours, gossiping, excluding others from a group or making others look foolish or unintelligent. This form of bullying is most common among girls.
— Children who bully are 37% more likely than children who do not bully to commit criminal offences as adults. (Public Safety)
— Cyberbullying involves the use of communication technologies such as the Internet, social networking sites, websites, email, text messaging and instant messaging to repeatedly intimidate or harass others.
Cyberbullying includes:
— Sending mean or threatening emails or text/instant messages.
— Posting embarrassing photos of someone online.
— Creating a website to make fun of others.
— Pretending to be someone by using their name.
— Tricking someone into revealing personal or embarrassing information and sending it to others.
— Cyberbullying affects victims in different ways than traditional bullying. It can follow a victim everywhere 24 hours a day, seven days a week, from school, to the mall and all the way into the comfort of their home – usually safe from traditional forms of bullying.
— Source, RCMP
SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTER
THE WEEK: Busting the myth that council members come with a blank slate
The Old Guard faction of Comox Valley political activists has been trying for decades to create a cohesive voting block
Jonathan Kerr: He’s delivered on housing, environment and recruiting 13 new family doctors since elected
Dr. Jonathan Kerr stresses transparency and accountability as key councillor attributes and says it’s up to Comox voters whether he deserves to serve a full term on the Town Council
Jenn Meilleur: Active volunteer and advocate for community, collaboration and climate change
Jenn Meilleur is seeking a first term on the Comox Town Council to advocate for community development, environmental stewardship and a more collaborative decision-making process
Will Cole-Hamilton: Progressives can be strong financial managers
Will Cole-Hamilton is a collaborator by nature and a proponent of sound financial management. He is seeking a second term to continue his work on meeting the challenge of climate change, affordable housing and safe transportation options
Melanie McCollum: Finance background has created savings, new grant revenue for city
Seeking a second term on Courtenay City Council, Melanie McCollum will focus on housing issues and rolling out the updated OCP. She defends the city’s traffic improvements against a misinformation campaign spread by another candidate
Doug Hillian: A balanced view between big picture issues and those that affect daily lives
The recently retired two-time recipient of the Governor General’s Exemplary Service Medal adds traffic safety like the 17th Street improvements to his list of top priorities for another term on Courtenay City Council
David Frisch: Carrying forward the vision already underway and implementing the new OCP
Incumbent David Frisch is seeking a third term on Courtenay City Council to continue work on housing diversity, safe routes for kids to get to school and finding a strategy that maintains downtown as a pleasant place
The bullying is not restricted to male perpetrators, either. As a female employed in male dominated fields for most of my working years, I have experienced a fair bit of bullying, as well as some great support from coworkers who cared more about my work than what was under my clothing. I have served on a variety of boards and committees as well, but was astounded to see the level of manipulation and bullying done to both staff and fellow volunteers by the first female to claim the top position in a local nonprofit recently. Some people just don’t seem to be able to properly deal with any form or perception of power 🙁
As Secretary-Treasurer of SD71 Board of School Trustees for 25 years, I witnessed plenty of bullying as well as being the recipient of bullying. Very interesting comments by Wayne Bradley, who also felt some bullying. The bullies were most often males, but sometimes from females feeling “power”. I am sure Wayne Bradley recalls one male bully in particular during that era. Having a difference of opinion on boards and committees is healthy. Respect for people with a different prospective grows the organization.
I was a school trustee for 5 years in the early 1980s when the ruling Social Credit government launched a concerted attack on our education system.
As a school trustee I was involved in a very heated campaign to oppose these funding cuts, and as a trade unionist I felt a strong personal commitment of solidarity to those workers who were under attack, losing their rights and often their jobs.
My work from these two perspectives made me a very high profile news-maker and a lot of vitriol was unleashed at me as a result. That alone was of little concern to me and I understand that political struggle can get very heavy at times If you can’t take the heat, stay out of the kitchen (and keep your mouth shut!).
I expected a lot of push back and got it! Fair enough, but the several anonymous death threats were definitely over the top. This became a campaign of vitriol that had a lot of disturbing aspects as though I (and by association, all the hundreds of folks engaged in the struggle) had no right to our opinions. The leaders of this bullying and intimidation campaign left a very bitter legacy as a result of their tactics which still resonates with many in the Valley.
I’m sure that some of those folks who helped orchestrate this slander and worse against me and others are the same folks who engage in the political bullying that Mayor Baird has experienced. Some people have long held a sense of their entitlement to control the nature of this community and can get pretty nasty when pushed hard enough. We made a huge stride toward a more inclusive and diverse approach to our politics in our last civic elections. Congratulations to Mayor Baird for helping to create a community where the toxic stench of politcal bullying is only a bad memory of those days back when….
Best wishes to Leslie in this regard. Kudos for having the courage to bring this issue to the forefront. Respecting someone’s opinion and agreeing to disagree on issues with civility seems to be a core character in serious decline in politics, which if somewhat true, models terrible examples of behaviour to citizens especially our youth! Thankfully, there are still worthy role models like Leslie! Best wishes for a positive outcome!
Nice to have the awareness meeting but how about taking on some of these bully groups. A plan of action.