Courtenay’s controversial Sixth Street Bridge: Whose idea was it?
Like almost every other British Columbia municipality, before the city even starts work on next year’s financial plan, most of the budget has already been spent or dictated by the province.
Things like water and sewer services, police and fire services, recreational and cultural services and financial items like amortization and debt interest will have already consumed about 65 percent of the revenue. When it comes to general operations, your elected officials have limited discretionary choices.
This may be why some candidates in this year’s municipal election have zeroed in on the incumbent’s capital expenditures. It’s a common misconception that council has complete discretion over its Capital Improvement Plan. But, in reality, only a small portion of each Capital Budget has not been mandated by the province or failing infrastructure.
It is true, however, that each new mayor and council prioritizes a few projects for their multi-year Capital Improvement Plan (CIP).
For better or worse, the current City Council included the recently opened Sixth Street Bridge in its last capital plan. The pedestrian and cycling bridge became an instant lightning rod for critics and candidates in the Oct. 17 municipal elections.
One of those disparaging the bridge this year is mayoral candidate Manno Theos, a former Courtenay Councillor, who championed the bridge decision in 2019. Seven years later, he’s calling it “The bridge to nowhere,” while his supporters call it “unnecessary spending.”
Let’s take a closer look at how the Sixth Street bridge bounced around and came to life.
WHOSE IDEA WAS IT?
The bridge has a storied history involving many people and many design variations. It had more starts and stops than a vehicle trying to cross the 17th St. bridge on a Friday afternoon.
The original idea for a Courtenay foot bridge at Sixth Street arose during the 1980s, when it was mentioned in the Official Community Plan. It popped up again, during the planning for Simms Park in the 1990s. A sketch of the park design shows the bridge.
IT’S A GO – But the bridge started to get real legs in 2005 when the Sunrise Rotary Club supported the concept and made plans to construct it using community donations and volunteer labor. They envisioned a Timber frame structure.
NO GO – The city abandoned the Rotary Club plan after engineers ruled out the wood construction for various reasons, including maintenance and public safety.
IT’S A GO – Then, in 2016, business and property owners in the downtown district held a charrette in conjunction with the city to gather ideas for a downtown revitalization. The Downtown Playbook document that emerged from those planning sessions included a bridge for foot and bicycle traffic.
NO GO – But then-mayor Larry Jangula did not make the bridge a priority, so the city never followed up on that item from the Downtown Playbook.
IT’S ANOTHER GO – When a new mayor and council were elected in 2018, they engaged staff to focus on the Downtown Playbook and an update to the city’s Official Community Plan. The bridge became a piece in council’s movement toward more active transportation corridors and the further development of Simms Park.
NOPE, STILL A NO GO – The Sixth Street bridge stalled again, however, because the city discovered that for public safety reasons, a restoration of the Fifth Street bridge had to take priority.
Before the Fifth Street project started, city staff floated an option to add four-foot wide cantilevers for cyclists on both sides of the bridge. This would have cost $1 million (less than the Sixth Street bridge option), but it would have added an extra six weeks to the partial bridge closure for construction.
A GO? – Council leaned toward approving the cantilevers plan, although staff later cooled on the idea in favor of returning to the Sixth Street bridge plan. Cantilevers would be less expensive. They could be constructed quicker than an entire new bridge.
THE TURNING POINT
NOT SO FAST — At the Sept. 3, 2019 council meeting, Jenny Deters, a business owner and president of the Downtown Business Association, led a delegation on behalf of 200 business owners and the Chamber of Commerce to oppose the cantilevering option and to urge council to build the Sixth Street bridge.
You can watch the video of her presentation and council members’s response starting at 20:23 in the video below.
Deters said a majority of business owners supported the Fifth Street bridge restoration and also supported “alternate modes of transportation and more cycling to get around the Valley.”
She told council that Downtown businesses would suffer lost revenue during to the six month Fifth Street bridge closure. And that they feared another six weeks to add cantilevers could be catastrophic. Deters praised Sixth Street as a better investment. She predicted that a foot and cycle bridge at Sixth Street would become a tourist attraction and a beautification of the downtown area.
Deters went so far as to call the bridge a long-time vision of past councils and citizens and that the bridge was “strategic to the revitalization” of downtown Courtenay. She pleaded with council to “do the bridge sooner than later,” and drop the plan for cantilevers.
MANNO TO THE RESCUE – Councillor Manno Theos praised Deters’s presentation at the 2019 meeting and endorsed her plea to build the Sixth Street bridge instead of adding cantilevers. And he also made a prediction, “This (decision for cantilevers versus Sixth Street) will be an issue that is going to end up defining this council.” See his comments starting at 30:55 in the video.
If the council voted to proceed with cantilevers, Theos said, they would pay a heavy political price. He warned that voters might toss them out of office.
“It’s going to be a hurricane for many of the councillors sitting at this table. We claimed the downtown core was one of our biggest issues … if we fail you (Downtown) now, we are going to be judged three years from now (2022 elections), certainly.”
In his effusive support for building the Sixth Street bridge, Theos went on to say that adding cantilevers would eliminate the possibility of a future bridge at Sixth Street bridge because doing both was not possible, “Especially now with significant tax increases coming forward at us.”
Theos said he supported a bridge at Sixth Street for safety reasons and also “moving it into nature … a more nature setting.”
Finally, in 2020, about 40 years after the idea originated, council approved the Sixth Street bridge and included it in the city’s capital budget. Council didn’t know if or when they would build the bridge, but it was a requirement to include the project in their capital plan in order to apply for grants.
IT’S A GO, AGAIN – When the federal government awarded Courtenay a $2.5 million grant, the project suddenly became a go. It was the largest federal grant for an active transportation project in Canadian history.
MAYBE NOT – But, in the years following the Covid pandemic, prices had escalated for everything across North America. The original cost estimate of $4 million to $6 million leaped to nearly $11 million (the exact cost will be known this fall when the accounting is completed).
Faced with such an increase, at its March 12, 2025 meeting, the council again considered dropping the project. They had three options to consider:
1) approve the bridge at the higher cost;
2) refer the matter back to the engineering department to examine previous design options to see if there was a less expensive solution;
or 3) cancel the project entirely.
Councillors were divided on what to do. Will Cole-Hamilton urged council to choose the second option to have engineering staff review other viable bridge designs. However, a council majority voted to go ahead with the bridge.
YES, YES – In the end, the council decided to proceed because the cost would only keep escalating and the city would lose the federal grant.
Courtenay Mayor Bob Wells told Decafnation that he supported the bridge when the cost was $6.9 million. But he hesitated at the cost escalation.
“But with the grants of $5.55 million, our final cost would be less than the original $6.9 million,” Wells said. “As the project finished ahead of schedule and under budget, it will cost our taxpayers even less.”
WHAT IT COST
The city obtained $5.55 million in grants for the bridge, including $2.5 million from the Active Transportation Fund, $2.555 million from the Growing Communities Fund and $500,000 from the Canada Community Building Fund. The city is expected to use $3.75 million in long-term borrowing and $1.8 million from surplus and reserves.
The final cost of the bridge is unknown, though it is expected to come in under $11 million. The final accounting of bridge costs will complete this fall.
Advance voting
Advance voting begins on Oct. 7, to find locations and times for your jurisdictions, click these links:
Comox Valley Regional District
SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTER
The “Seven-Day Building Permit Rule” in Comox, a flurry of motions in Courtenay
A Comox Valley developer has reportedly met the Seven-Day Rule for a building permit in Comox, most likely changing the Town Council’s consideration of downzoning the site. In Courtenay, notices of motion include a review of city operations, a deputy mayor position and freezing of council salaries for two years.
The Week: We’ve got the data! A look ahead at busy councils, and Good/Bad news
Any human with a computer has access to all the local government financial data they could ever want … and more. Unless you’re a financial statement nerd and need the real thing, check out our spreadsheets today that play your government’s greatest hits. Plus, tension-packed council meetings expected in Comox and Courtenay.
To frame the current zoning conflict in Comox about one property minimizes the democratic process
The whole timeline and background story about how the Town of Comox got into conflict with the owner of 1890 Comox Avenue is long and complicated, but the essence of the dispute is much simpler: the community at large does not want what this developer is offering and they couldn’t have made that point more clear than the Oct. 17 election results
The Week: The sun still rises every morning, just a lot later than usual, and other stuff
The Week looks at the time change chaos created by former BC Premier John Horgan’s sketchy poll and asks, “Why?” And then we turn to a candidate who this week announced her candidacy for the 2029 federal election and ask, “Why?” Finally we take a deeper dive into hospital boards with Doug Hillian and throw out some data about data centers
Inaugural meeting: Comox Council considers a six-storey project, Mayor Minions’s address
The Town of Comox held its inaugural council meeting Wednesday night so new councillors could take the oath of office and Mayor Nicole Minions could deliver her State of the Town address. But unlike traditional inaugural meetings, this one required the new council to address a development project approved by the previous council that conflicts with the election mandate opposed to six-storey buildings in the downtown core.
Courtenay City Council majority overrules new Mayor Theos’s appointments
Manno Theos may have won the Courtenay mayor’s office but he lost the first battle with the City Council this week, as four councillors objected to his proposed appointments to the regional district board and other assignments. Instead, the council majority passed their own list of appointments, leaving Theos off the CVRD board.
Mayor Brown gets emotional, says the village inspires her even on the hardest days
Mayor Vickey Brown and four Village Council members were sworn into office Monday night and accepted appointment to various boards and committees. In her inaugural address Brown acknowledged the importance of provincial funding and asked the community to leave the campaign behind and now focus on collaboration and team-building.
Will Cole-Hamilton bucks the trend, flips Courtenay Comox riding to NDP
More than four thousand fewer Green Party voters showed up this year and incumbent Conservative MLA Brennan Day lost 787 votes as the NDP won in Courtenay-Comox by about a three percent margin. The ‘blue wave’ was strong across the province, however, taking 64 of the 93 seats in the BC Legislature
THE WEEK: NDP trails BC Conservatives in polls, undecideds will determine outcome
This week: Province-wide polling indicates the NDP have fallen behind BC Conservatives heading into Election Day and that undecided NDP and Green Party voters will decide the outcome in swing ridings like Courtenay-Comox. Also, what should British Columbians think about the Alberta secession referendum? And if you suffer from Long Covid or other chronic diseases, funding cuts to virtual care may affect you
Voting stats show some positive trends in the local government elections
The Comox Valley’s 2026 local government election results show more women sought public office and were elected this year, especially in the Town of Comox. Plus overall voter turnout increased over the last municipal election in 2022. And, we look back to 1949, the year one new council member was born.
Well done George! So interesting to read the history of this project. A true piece of journalism, something we lack in this community.
Thank you for your commitment to Decafination.
Very interesting article, thanks so much for the research! As someone who has only lived here since 2021 it’s interesting to hear about the history. Personally I felt that the bridge was too expensive and not the right priority (even though I’m a cyclist and cycle semi regularly over the 5th Street bridge), but you can see why it got built with the years of momentum behind it and the grant… and longer term seeing the city’s plans for that area on the downtown side of the bridge you can definitely see the potential future appeal, so hopefully it was a good long term decision…
Wonderfully written and researched post on the 6th street bridge in Courtenay. I think it is the necessary antidote to articles like the popular magazine article that advised tourists to “keep trucking” through Courtenay because it is just a gauntlet of big box stores and greasy fast food chains. Like nothing else the 6th street bridge says linger here–Courtenay is an enjoyable place to be. I ride the bridge almost daily and am enamored with this celebration of Courtenay as a wonderful place to be/visit. I am delighted that the bridge is being combined with new trails and scenic lookouts to emphasize our connection to Sims Park and the Courtenay River. My vote will go to those who care about the quality of life in our community.
There will be little actual “transportation” use of this bridge until an overpass for this traffic is built over the highway, lining up with the edge of the farm behind Superstore. This would open the whole of East Courtenay up to downtown for bikes and pedestrians, as right now getting across the highway at Ryan Rd is a nightmare (especially for bikes). A corridor without car traffic would be beneficial to those going downtown, where, by the way, there are few places to secure bikes or sit and rest. Downtown needs to cater more to this group, both in the short and long terms.
Well well, what a tiny bit of historical memory unveils!
This story shows that we need more of this kind of reporting.
This is priceless! I love history. The armchair freedum cockasses will lose their zhit. I wonder how the newest councillors will react when reality takes their red crayons away.
Well done George.
I keep hearing people dismiss the Sixth Street Bridge as a “bridge to nowhere,” including mayoral candidate Manno Theos.
I find that framing incredibly immature. Simms Millennium Park is not “nowhere.” Neither are the Riverway, the trail network or downtown. It’s a transportation corridor connecting important public spaces in our community.
And after reading the history of the project, the criticism feels even more hollow. This wasn’t some whimsical pet project dreamed up by the current council. The idea goes back decades, appeared repeatedly in city planning, had support from downtown businesses and community groups, and even Manno Theos himself strongly advocated for the Sixth Street bridge in 2019.
There’s a broader issue here too. We seem to be living in an increasingly hyper-individualistic culture where public investments are judged almost entirely through the lens of “What does this do for me?”
That’s a terrible way to build a community.
You might not ride a bike. You might not walk across this bridge. You might not spend much time at Simms Park. That doesn’t make those things worthless. Communities invest in parks, trails, transportation, recreation and public spaces because they contribute to the greater good and because we’re building a city for people who will live here long after us.
It’s okay to invest in future generations.
By all means, debate the cost or whether it was the right priority. But calling it a “bridge to nowhere” is a lazy dismissal of what the project actually is, where it came from, and the people in this community who will use it.
Well said!!
Hi George,
The 6th street bridge is substantially built. We walked it a few weeks ago. Lots of people on the bridge. It is nice, but we were not all that comfortable with the troubled people in Sims park, or in the shadows of 6th street. We have walked Cliffe , near the connect centre and felt less comfortable.
We have launched the canoe in Sim,s park at the slough and canoed the beatutfull , scenic Courtenay River.What a amazing place to be. Canoeing under the bridge, it appears to be as substantiall built as above. An expensive build.
We keep our eyes open when in Sims park. There are often troubled people in this park. It is not always a comfortable place to be.
The less fortunate are also members of our community and have a right to be here too.
Yes Terry, of course. We often see such disadvantaged people in wheel chairs , accompanied by caregivers at the Airpark. What a wonderful place to walk.
At some point in time, all “disadvantaged ” folk will be appropriately housed in specialized facilities, rather than streets and parks. Local politicians have a big role in public safety . Hopefully this election will elect those who actively seek a solution.
I so enjoyed this story!