Councillors Thomas McDevitt, right, and Dick Clancy during the RCMP’s quarterly report to Courtenay City Council — Leif Jason photo
THE WEEK: Hamir to chair CVRD – Confusion at City Council – City crime down
Courtenay RCMP detachment Inspector Scott Mercer told the Courtenay City Council this week that overall violent crime decreased by 18 percent over last year during the period from July through September.The RCMP reports crime statistics to the city every quarter of each fiscal year, which begins April 1.
In response to a question from Councillor Thomas McDevitt, Inspector Mercer said violent crime in 2026 was down from the previous year.
In the second quarter, police responded to two percent fewer calls in total than last year, according to RCMP data. Along with the drop in violent crimes, property crimes also dropped by 12 percent and drugs or other substances crimes went down by 11 per cent.
The most common type of violent crime for the period was assault, and most of those were between people who knew each other, Mercer said. And most of those calls were to either the Connect Warming Centre and The Lodge.
Intimate Partner violence incidents in which the RCMP engaged were down by 23 percent over all types of domestic conflict. However, Spousal-partner assault was up by 47 percent over the previous year.
Councillor Evan Jolicoeur noted that the Comox Valley Transition Society is looking for a second facility to shelter women and their children escaping violence and that this is the third consecutive quarter that the number of assaults has not improved.
Councillor Thomas McDevitt said that domestic violence generally goes up during recessions and that improving people’s cost of living issues would have a holistically positive impact on these crimes.
Inspector Mercer told council that the biggest driver of the city’s increase in traffic crimes was the number of youths operating electric motorbikes and scooters. The RCMP is working with the school district and parents to explain the liabilities and physical harm that can result from unsafe behaviors.
Mercer said officers do not chase or pursue young offenders on electric vehicles because that creates other dangers. They have identified some of the offenders, who were approached later with their parents.
SOME CHAOS, VERBAL ATTACKS AT CITY HALL
The Courtenay City Council agenda for this week’s meeting appeared relatively light, perhaps even promising a smooth three-hour ride. Instead, it quickly devolved into a four-hour and thirty-nine minute mismanaged train wreck.
The problems were mostly procedural, and there were many of them. They caused confusion at times, led to mistakes at other times and generally made the meeting longer than necessary.
Mayor Manno Theos often appeared lost during the meeting, despite his 20 years of council experience, constantly turning to City Manager Goeff Garbutt or others for advice on what to do next.
As a result, the star performer on the live streamed meeting was not the mayor or council members. Instead, that honor goes to Adriana Proton, the city’s Manager of Legislative Services, whose procedural advice was called on many times to untangle a mess the mayor and council had created.
There also was a serious altercation in the gallery noticed by some staff and a few council members. The mayor, apparently unaware of the incident, did not call for decorum in the room.
RULES, RULES
The procedural trouble began during the council’s consideration of a request by Swing City Golf for council to support its application to the BC Liquor and Cannabis Regulation Branch. Swing City wants to expand its business hours to 2 a.m. for special events.
City staff had given council three options to deal with the application: To approve giving support, to deny it, or to ask for more information before deciding. Council was divided for and against, and for various reasons, had not reached any consensus.
Then, Councillor Dick Clancy moved that the application be approved. Theos called the motion failed and moved council on to a discussion about how to use the city’s share of the MRDT tax.
Cue, Adriana Proton.
Later, when the MRDT discussion finished, Proton pointed out the motion to support Swing City had not been seconded, so there was no official decision made. She said staff needed to respond to the applicant in some way and, as it stood, council had made no decision.
This led to more discussions, and clarifications and ultimately a five minute recess, presumably to figure out how to walk themselves out of a botched procedure. Council ultimately asked for more information.
But back to the MRDT tax discussion. Councillor Dick Clancy created more turmoil when he made a wild-card motion during the discussion about how best to use the city reserve of Municipal Regional District Tax monies to support non-profits. The province requires a plan by Nov. 30.
Councillors normally give notice of motions at one meeting before actually moving them on the record at the next meeting. But Clancy dropped one without any notice and it caught other council members off guard.
And because the motion came before the council had finished discussion of the original staff recommendation to comply with the provincial deadline, it took a half-hour to figure out what they were voting on and how to straighten things out.
Were they voting on approving the MRDT plan or on Clancy’s motion? Was there even a motion to approve the MRDT plan?
Cue Adriana Proton, again.
Eventually, Clancy’s motion without notice was considered and severed into two parts. Council approved the MRDT Plan to meet the Nov. 30 deadline. But the Clancy motion to shift non-profit funding requests to a competitive request-for-proposal system was deferred to the council’s future strategic planning session.
Then, the chaos continued when Councillor Evan Jolicoeur asked the mayor and council to suspend the rules and consider four motions that night, without notice. Two of the motions related to supporting nominating him as a candidate in a Federation of Canadian Municipalities by-election, and two motions related to expenses to attend the FCM’s four meetings each year. Jolicoceur said he asked for the consideration without notice because the deadline for nominations was the next day, Nov. 19.
That’s when Councillor Rosanna Chamberlin, attending via Zoom, said that Jolicoeur’s request to suspend rules and consider a motion without notice required a two-thirds majority vote (5-2) to he granted. For some reason, that rule did not come up when Councillor Clancy made a motion without notice earlier during the MRDT discussion.
Cue, Adriana Proton, again.
She advised the council to separate Jolicoeur’s four motions and to vote on whether to consider them without notice one at a time.
Theos, Clancy and Chamberlin opposed considering the motions to support Jolicoeur for the national board, knowing that the nomination deadline would pass before council met again. If Jolicoeur brings the motions back to the council’s next meeting, they would only require a majority vote to pass. Each of these motions lost by a 4-3 vote, but needed five votes in favor to meet the two-thirds rule.
Chamberlain also argued against considering the last two of Jolicoeur’s motions regarding expenses because she said the city would save some money by not paying for his expenses to attend the four FCM meetings. Much debate occurred, and the last two motions were carried with only Chamberlin opposed on one.
Except, the council did not then actually vote on approving or defeating the two funding motions they agreed to consider. They had only voted not to consider the nomination motions, which had a deadline. But they had voted to hear the funding motions, but did not consider them. It was confusing.
However, former councillor Will Cole-Hamilton who served on the FCM, told Decafnation after the meeting that the City of Courtenay did not pay any of his expenses after 2023. They were all covered by a Union of British Columbia Municipalities travel fund for small communities, which Jolicoeur could also access.
VERBAL ATTACK IN THE GALLERY
Perhaps the most deplorable incident of the meeting occurred in the public gallery when one person repeatedly launched verbal attacks on another person just before and during the five-minute recess to sort out the Swing City liquor licence difficulty, and then again later after the dinner break. The attacks were loud enough for the whole room to hear and included, at times, yelling across the room and finger pointing, according to eyewitnesses.
Councillors Jolicoeur and McDevitt checked in with the target of the attacks and offered sympathy and support. Councillor Clancy approached the targeted person during the dinner break confrontation, but chose to speak about a charitable donation he had made rather than directly address the incident.
There are no security guards present at council meetings.
Jolicoeur told Decafnation that later in the meeting, he had an opportunity to speak to Mayor Theos about the attacks, who seemed to be unaware of the incident. They agreed that because at that time only a few people remained in the gallery, the decorum issue should be addressed at a future meeting.
By the time councillors emerged from the usual in-camera session that follows the regular meeting, it was past 10 pm.
HAMIR ELECTED AS CVRD CHAIR
The Comox Valley Regional District board held its inaugural meeting this week that was part politics, part business and part orientation for the directors.
The board acclaimed Arzeena Hamir, the newly re-elected Area B representative, as its chair and also acclaimed Courtenay Councillor Wendy Morin as vice-chair. Hamir previously served from 2018 to 2022.
In her opening remarks, Hamir said she hoped the board would get a lot of work done. She many of the directors had gotten earfuls of the problems and issues in the community, such as affordability, climate and the unhoused/
“I also want to affirm that when we do our work, we also want to do it with joy and with partnership,” she said. “Because this is hard work and we do need to stay grounded and in good mental health.”
Chief Administration Officer James Warren said directors would receive background information on bylaws and other items before the meetings to help them get up to speed. Only four of the 10 directors served the board in the previous term, one served a term four years ago and the other five have no regional district experience.
That means many directors will have a larger learning curve about the CVRD itself and on the background of regional district issues.
Vice-Chair Morin told Decafnation that, “There are some big items coming up this term, including in recreation, transportation, sewage, water, updating the Regional Growth Strategy, and with the new Housing Authority. We will all need to be on our toes.”
AND IN OTHER NEWS …
GOOD NEWS – Four years after the Comox Valley Regional District filed a lawsuit against the ship-wrecking operation in Union Bay, the case will finally come to trial. The BC Supreme Court will hear the case starting on Nov. 25. It is scheduled to last three days. The CVRD filed the lawsuit in 2022 and expanded the scope of the civil claim in March of this year. The CVRD is attempting to stop operations by the company, Deep Water Recovery.
MOSTLY GOOD NEWS – Canadians think Prime Minister Mark Carney has improved our trade relationships with other countries and our standing in the world, but has not made a significant impact on domestic issues, according to a new Angus Reid Institute poll released Monday. The domestic issues include health care, housing affordability, crime and public safety and taxes. The poll also found most Canadians feel that the PM has helped national unity in the wake of Alberta’s referendum.
NOT SO GOOD NEWS FOR SOME – The new BC provincial government officially took office yesterday and Premier-designate Lorne Doerkson is expected to make some quick changes that don’t require legislation. The Legislature may not convene until spring.
Among the early possibilities is an order for provincial employees to return to government workplaces, which has sparked controversial debate around productivity, traffic issues in the Victoria area and the expense of restarting leased office spaces.
How will a return to work order affect provincial employees working remotely from the Comox Valley? The best case scenario, according to one employee who asked not to be named, is that they could work from one of the many local provincial office buildings, such as the Service Center on Cliffe Avenue.
If you are a provincial employee, let Decafnation know how returning to provincial offices might affect you.
REALLY BAD NEWS – Ocean Networks Canada reports water temperatures around Vancouver Island have reached a record 8.21 degrees C at 400 metres below the surface. That’s 2.49 degrees warmer than average at that depth and about one degree warmer than the historic record in 2019. That’s good for swimmers as the water also warms closer to coastlines, but terrible for salmon, herring and marine mammals.
Please limit your comments to 250 words
WHAT IS THE ECOLOGICAL ACCOUNTING PROCESS (EAP)?
Ecological Accounting Process — “The EAP approach begins by first recognizing the importance of a stream in a natural state and then asking: how can we maintain those ecological values while allowing the stream to be used for drainage,” says Jim Dumont, Engineering Applications Authority with the Partnership for Water Sustainability in BC.
SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTER
The “Seven-Day Building Permit Rule” in Comox, a flurry of motions in Courtenay
A Comox Valley developer has reportedly met the Seven-Day Rule for a building permit in Comox, most likely changing the Town Council’s consideration of downzoning the site. In Courtenay, notices of motion include a review of city operations, a deputy mayor position and freezing of council salaries for two years.
The Week: We’ve got the data! A look ahead at busy councils, and Good/Bad news
Any human with a computer has access to all the local government financial data they could ever want … and more. Unless you’re a financial statement nerd and need the real thing, check out our spreadsheets today that play your government’s greatest hits. Plus, tension-packed council meetings expected in Comox and Courtenay.
To frame the current zoning conflict in Comox about one property minimizes the democratic process
The whole timeline and background story about how the Town of Comox got into conflict with the owner of 1890 Comox Avenue is long and complicated, but the essence of the dispute is much simpler: the community at large does not want what this developer is offering and they couldn’t have made that point more clear than the Oct. 17 election results
The Week: The sun still rises every morning, just a lot later than usual, and other stuff
The Week looks at the time change chaos created by former BC Premier John Horgan’s sketchy poll and asks, “Why?” And then we turn to a candidate who this week announced her candidacy for the 2029 federal election and ask, “Why?” Finally we take a deeper dive into hospital boards with Doug Hillian and throw out some data about data centers
Inaugural meeting: Comox Council considers a six-storey project, Mayor Minions’s address
The Town of Comox held its inaugural council meeting Wednesday night so new councillors could take the oath of office and Mayor Nicole Minions could deliver her State of the Town address. But unlike traditional inaugural meetings, this one required the new council to address a development project approved by the previous council that conflicts with the election mandate opposed to six-storey buildings in the downtown core.
Courtenay City Council majority overrules new Mayor Theos’s appointments
Manno Theos may have won the Courtenay mayor’s office but he lost the first battle with the City Council this week, as four councillors objected to his proposed appointments to the regional district board and other assignments. Instead, the council majority passed their own list of appointments, leaving Theos off the CVRD board.
Mayor Brown gets emotional, says the village inspires her even on the hardest days
Mayor Vickey Brown and four Village Council members were sworn into office Monday night and accepted appointment to various boards and committees. In her inaugural address Brown acknowledged the importance of provincial funding and asked the community to leave the campaign behind and now focus on collaboration and team-building.
The Week: Manno’s speech, buying beds in CR, high five for Johns and the bird for Gunn
‘The Week’ is back — a weekly commentary on whatever comes our way. This week, a demo inaugural speech for new Mayor Manno Theos, how Comox Valley taxpayers are funding new long-term care beds in Campbell River, imagining Josie Osborne as the new BC NDP party leader and a bunch of other stuff.
Will Cole-Hamilton bucks the trend, flips Courtenay Comox riding to NDP
More than four thousand fewer Green Party voters showed up this year and incumbent Conservative MLA Brennan Day lost 787 votes as the NDP won in Courtenay-Comox by about a three percent margin. The ‘blue wave’ was strong across the province, however, taking 64 of the 93 seats in the BC Legislature
THE WEEK: NDP trails BC Conservatives in polls, undecideds will determine outcome
This week: Province-wide polling indicates the NDP have fallen behind BC Conservatives heading into Election Day and that undecided NDP and Green Party voters will decide the outcome in swing ridings like Courtenay-Comox. Also, what should British Columbians think about the Alberta secession referendum? And if you suffer from Long Covid or other chronic diseases, funding cuts to virtual care may affect you
An informative summary of events this past week and a view of things to come. As a former BC public servant (long retired) it seems to me that there are some services provided by government employees that can only be done in person. I was a social worker, and while aspects of that service provision can be done remotely, face to face is always preferable.
I enjoyed most of my in office work experiences and the sharing of care and concern and the value of working with both clients and fellow workers. I guess I’m old school on this subject.
Interesting report.
I look forward to Arzeena Hamir as Chair of the CVRD board, providing leadership on the issue of providing more affordable services with the four Goverments serving 76, ooo customers in the Comox Valley. Combined service deliver costs, here, are significantly higher , per capita , than the two government system, North of the Comox Valley, over the last two terms.
During the election campaign, Arzeena indicted that the chronically unhousable in Courtenay, were not in her jurisdiction, although she was supportive of a solution. I suggest that this problem should be addressed as a Region, and Arzeena, as chair, can make a difference.
I,m optimistic that the new board will make progress over the next four years.
Excellent report and summation.
One might be forgiven for ruminating on the old saying about electing clowns and the resultant circus.
Cheers
I’m astounded that you missed Evan’s complete blunder in respect to the use of a lot off Braidwood for construction materials staging. Then there was McDevitt’s fantasy about drunken fiends wielding 7 irons like claymores. As to the “altercation”, I’d suggest you get better “eyewitnesses”.
Great summation of the meeting. Thank you.