Jonathan Kerr: He’s delivered on housing, environment and recruiting 13 new family doctors since elected

Jonathan Kerr: He’s delivered on housing, environment and recruiting 13 new family doctors since elected

Elected last year to fill out the term of a councillor who resigned, Dr. Jonathan Kerr is seeking re-election to a full term on Comox Council

Jonathan Kerr: He’s delivered on housing, environment and recruiting 13 new family doctors since elected

By

Dr. Jonathan Kerr is seeking re-election to a full term on the Comox Town Council. Kerr has been a council member since voters elected him 10 months ago to fill the seat of resigning councillor Pat McKenna.

Kerr earned his Doctor of Medicine from the University of Toronto in 2006 and did Post-Graduate Family Medicine training at Queen’s University. He practiced family medicine in Belleville, Ont. prior to moving to the Comox Valley.

He and his wife and their two children moved to the Valley in late 2014, and he joined the Sea Cove Medical Clinic in 2015, where he is currently the lead physician.

Kerr served as president of the Ontario College of Family Physicians and served on its board for many years, including one year as chair. He has also served on the board of directors for the College of Family Physicians Canada and currently sits on the Advisory Committee for the Comox Valley Division of Family Practice.

He is the founder and chair of the new Comox Valley Family Physician Recruitment and Retention Task Force.

Kerr actively competes in the sport of Biathlon and coaches youth eight to 18 in rifle marksmanship and cross-country skiing with the Vancouver Island Biathlon Club. He’s also a volunteer with the Brooklyn Creek Watershed Society, and previously served on the Coalition to End Homelessness, Dawn to Dawn Action on Homelessness Society and is treasurer of the Navigate School Parent Advisory Council.

 

Why should voters re-elect you?

Kerr says he has really enjoyed his role on council since last November, especially the opportunity to connect with residents. The constituency work energizes him, he says, making him a bit of an outlier among the many policy wonks who hold public office. 

Kerr says being a town councillor is similar to his role as a family doctor.

“You listen to people’s concerns, make a diagnosis and work with them on a plan to fix it,” he said. “It’s a real high, a beautiful moment when I can make a difference in people’s lives.”

In his medical practice and now on council, Kerr operates on the ‘servant leadership model.’ He sees his job as serving people to improve their lives, the community and the environment.

He stresses transparency and accountability as key attributes of a good councillor.

“They are not just buzzwords. I take them seriously. After every meeting, I post my voting record on my website and I link to the time in the council video where I speak on each topic,” he said.

In his nine months on council, Kerr has made sure that he focused on what people told him they wanted during the nine-month public listening campaign he ran last year.

“It’s for the voters to decide if I deserve a full term after winning the byelection last fall,” he told Decafnation.

 

What are some of your key accomplishments?

During the byelection, Keer made it clear that he would have three priorities based on the extensive public information sessions he did prior to the byelection: affordable housing, climate change and the recruitment of new family doctors.

On affordable housing, Kerr says the town used to negotiate informally with developers for affordable housing units.

“Now, we have put that into a formal policy so everyone knows what it is,” he said.

The new policy requires developers to set aside 1.2 percent of their total rental units and 1.8 percent of condo units for the town. Comox will then partner with local non-profits to rent these out as truly affordable units.

“I had proposed 2.5 percent, which developers objected to, so we collaborated to agree on the new policy rates. I took some heat for this. Developers were not thrilled but it’s important to stand up for what’s best for the community,” he said.

Kerr says he would support a regional housing authority to manage all the affordable housing units in the Comox Valley. Others running in Comox and Courtenay have expressed support for a housing authority.

On climate change, Kerr helped drive passage of the new tree retention bylaw, which passed on a 4-3 vote. The first version of the tree bylaw required 25 percent retention and the new bylaw requires 30 percent.

“Again I proposed in my motion to make it 35 percent and we collaborated,” he said. “It was important to get this done before any development started in the Northeast Comox area.”

The Town Council also approved participation in the Comox Valley Regional District’s regional climate action initiative. Kerr moved that council adopt the Comox staff report on the possibility of adopting some of the Youth Climate Council’s Green New Deal proposals in the short, medium and long-term.

“I am supporting the Youth Council’s efforts to transition to a more climate change-friendly society,” he said.

Kerr has been especially successful in his campaign theme of recruiting more family doctors to the area.

“Immediately after I was elected last November, I called together a Comox Valley Family Physician Recruitment and Retention Task Force that included mayors, councillors, CAOs, representatives from the CV chamber, hospital and other sectors because it has to be a regional-wide effort,” he said. “The goal wasn’t to just bring doctors to Comox. It wouldn’t work if all our jurisdictions competed with each other. New doctors, wherever they live or set up practice in the Valley benefit us all.”

When Kerr started the task force, there were 14,000 Valley residents who didn’t have a family doctor (numbers were culled from the Comox Valley’s clinics’ wait lists and the province’s health registry).

Since Jan. 1, the group has recruited 13 new doctors; seven are already here and practicing and six are arriving this fall. And the Task Force has connected 5,500 people with doctors in the last 12 months. 

To accomplish that, Kerr’s Task Force formed a marketing strategy that examined what each community offered. They made videos of current doctors talking about why they love practicing here and posted them on social media.

When doctors come to visit, Kerr says the group has a Roll Out The Red Carpet plan to show the doctors and their families around the whole Comox Valley and try to remove any barriers that exist, such as finding temporary housing.

Staff at the Comox Valley Division of Family Practice coordinates the Task Force’s recruitment efforts, including finding out a doctor’s and their family’s needs and interests before they come to visit in order to tailor the sales pitch.

 

Goals for the next four years

Kerr says he doesn’t have any personal goals for the next four years, “just the ones Comox residents tell me are their top issues. Housing, climate and doctors are still at the top of the list. But I will be looking at some specific issues.”

One of those other issues would be to protect as much of the Northeast Comox forest land as possible – the area from Highland school down to the roundabout on both sides of Pritchard, mostly on the east side. The area includes 11 different parcels with multiple owners.

“The question here is how best to use this land,” he said.

The area is zoned R1 for residential single-family homes. But Comox already has the highest percentage of single-family homes: 66 percent. The national average is 51 percent.

“We need more rental units and townhouses,” Kerr said. “With the current housing market, single-family homes aren’t affordable housing for many people.”

There’s also the economic piece for taxpayers. It will take more than 30 years to pay back the cost of extending sewer and water infrastructure to the area.

“Why burden the town’s taxpayers with more unfunded liabilities?” he said. “Plus, it’s a beautiful forest and it would be a shame if it all came down. We should be able to find a balance among retaining trees, benefits to taxpayers, affordable housing and a mixture of housing types.”

Right now, Northeast Comox area property owners could build all single-family homes. But Kerr says it would be better to upzone and allow developers higher densities and make a plan for the whole area rather than dealing with each parcel piecemeal.

“We could have a discussion and find a compromise by looking at the whole area through a community benefits lens. I’m optimistic the developers will come to the table,” he said.

Also, the council will be updating the town’s Official Community Plan during the next term. Kerr wants to be a part of that for the inclusion of community-focused visions for social, environmental and reconciliation issues.

Kerr will also be looking at improving activities for teens with “so many new young families moving here,” and making streets safer and working with the BIA for a more vibrant downtown.

 

What is most misunderstood about the Council Town Council?

Kerr thinks some people believe that the council should limit itself to just dealing with water, sewer and potholes.

“These are all important things, but the role of the town and council is much more,” he said. “It’s not correct that councils are not supposed to do those things.”

The BC Community Charter, which gives municipal governments their authority, states a local government must “foster economic development, social and environmental well-being of its community.”

“Those are the exact lenses that I use in decision-making at council because that’s what Comox residents want and what the people who call me want,” he said.

“It’s the responsibility of elected officials to address the issues that matter while providing excellent core services,” he said. “Our updated Official Community Plan for Comox could look different depending on who Comox people elect. You could have a forward-thinking council or a group of regressive people.”
​​

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

WHERE AND WHEN TO VOTE

General Voting Day is Saturday, Oct. 15 for all local government positions.

Comox Valley Regional District

General Voting Day and advance voting take place at the CVRD building in Courtenay from 8 am to 8 pm.

Go to this link for General Voting Day locations in the three Electoral Areas.

Additional voting takes place on Oct. 6 from 9 am to 12 pm on Denman Island and on Oct. 6 from 2 pm to 5 pm on Hornby Island

Courtenay

Advance Voting begins on Wednesday October 5, 2022, 8 am to 8 pm at the Native Sons Hall, and again on Wednesday October 12, 2022, 8 am to 8 pm at the Florence Filberg Centre.

General Voting Day, Saturday, October 15, 2022, 8 am to 8 pm at the Queneesh Elementary School, and at the Florence Filberg Centre.

Comox

Advance voting begins Wednesday, October 5 from 8 a.m. – 8 p.m. at the Comox Community Centre, and on Saturday, October 8 from 10 a.m. – 2 p.m. at the Genoa Sail Building at Comox Marina, and again on Monday, October 10 from 10 a.m. – 2 p.m. at the Genoa Sail Building at Comox Marina, and on Wednesday, October 12 from 8 a.m. – 8 p.m. at the Comox Community Centre.

General Voting Day runs from 8 am to 8 pm on Oct. 15 at the Comox Community Centre.

Cumberland

All voting in the Village of Cumberland takes place from 8 am to 8 pm at the Cumberland Cultural Centre. Advance voting takes place on Oct. 5 and Oct. 12.

 

 

SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTER

Enter your email address to subscribe to the Decafnation newsletter.

More
Jenn Meilleur: Active volunteer and advocate for community, collaboration and climate change

Jenn Meilleur: Active volunteer and advocate for community, collaboration and climate change

Jenn Meilleur has an insider’s view of how the government process works and years of experience in working collaboratively

Jenn Meilleur: Active volunteer and advocate for community, collaboration and climate change

By

Jenn Meilleur is seeking a first term on the Comox Town Council. She is a systems change and dialogue facilitator currently working as the Manager of Community Disaster Recovery with Emergency Management BC.

She has worked with and for local governments since 2010. She started as a Program Manager (Policy Analyst) with the City of Vancouver when it adopted The Greenest City Action Plan in 2010 to become the greenest city in the world.

Meilleur moved to Comox Valley with her husband and two children in the spring of 2019. She grew up in Qualicum and graduated from Vancouver Island University when it was still called Malaspina College.

Jenn has two decades of experience leading and supporting initiatives and collaborative networks in the fields of sustainability and climate action, community development, organizational development and systems change. And she is an active volunteer in her community

She is the Board Co-Chair for LUSH Valley Food Action Society, a member of the local Food Policy Council and a member of the Coordinating Circle for the Comox Valley Community Health Network. She helped found a nature-based elementary school program and supported the creation of the Atl’ka7tsem/Howe Sound UNESCO Biosphere Region in the Salish Sea as a board member.

Jenn finds her inspiration in nature with gratitude on the unceded lands and waters of the K’ómoks First Nation in Comox with her husband, two children and many “four-legged friends.” She enjoys trail running, wild swimming, cycling and creative knitting projects. She is devoted to lifelong learning and is also an avid bookworm.

 

Why should voters elect you?

Meilleur is running for council because she has heard our youth’s growing anxiety about climate change and feels accountable as a Gen-X-er to do what she can for future generations. She believes there is a groundswell of worry about climate change.

“I want to take better care of nature through collaboration with others,” she told Decafnation. “It’s about the emergency. Like Greta Thornberg says, ‘we know we have to do better.’ But how do we do that?”

The three pillars of Meilleur’s campaign are community, collaboration and climate change.

She has spent her career on sustainability issues in the co-op sector, within government and for nonprofits. Through social innovation, she says she has brought people together to solve complex issues.

“I have an inside view of how the government process works and a skill of working collaboratively,” she said.

She says that running for office is not about what one person can do, but rather it’s about how this particular group of people can collaborate and what they can accomplish together.

“I have resisted campaigning with promises,” she said. “The public wants politics to be different. Council work should be a relational process, not a linear path. I would stress collaboration within the council and find new ways to bring citizens into the process.”

Meilleur would also like to bring more art into the community. She says studies have shown that road murals calm traffic and reduce accidents.

 

What are some of your key accomplishments?

As the previous regional coordinator for the Comox Valley Farm-to-School program, Meilleur brought together farmers, nonprofits, government staff and elected officials, and did this during the pandemic.

Working as a facilitator with the Community Health Network, Meilleur figured out how to bring all these diverse groups together to influence policy and make change. She organized and facilitated dialogue sessions and then captured stories that people shared.

Her campaign issues are affordable housing, climate change focus, local business, local food, reconciliation and creating equity for all people. And she believes that if people work collaboratively we can restore people’s faith in democracy.

A quote she particularly likes is from Lilla Watson about being interconnected: “If you have come here to help me, you are wasting your time. But if you have come because your liberation is bound up with mine, then let us work together.”

 

Goals for the next four years

Meilleur recognizes the importance of affordable housing to the community and would focus her efforts to continue building momentum for solutions.

“I would take a look at why Comox opted out and chose to not work regionally on this issue,” she said. “I believe affordable housing needs to be both local and regional to be effective.”

She says there is lots of good work being done in this field. She notes that Saanich fast-tracked garden suites and created 800 new housing units in one year and that the CV Seniors Support Society has started a housing program to match students with seniors who want to age in place. There was a plan for a Comox task force, but it was never formed, she said.

“Society has the answers and others are doing it,” she said. “Affordable housing has to go beyond new developments.”

But, Meilleur says, we must recognize that solutions that work in bigger cities don’t always work here. “We have to scale things for our size.”

The important lesson she takes from the council motion to require developers to set aside a percentage of below-market-rate units in all new developments is that government needs to work directly with whoever is impacted most when creating new programs – in this case, the developers.

Also, she says, it’s not always the government’s role to do something and maybe it’s better for the community or other partners to do certain things. Government should discern where to create conditions that encourage affordable housing rather than do it themselves.

“We need to consider co-housing, co-op housing and the whole spectrum of possibilities. It’s a regional issue and a complex problem that needs all parties at the table,” she said.

Climate change is also at the top of Meilleur’s priorities.

“I think of climate action both as reducing greenhouse gases and as protecting and restoring the environment,” she said.

For example, she says the town’s tree canopy bylaw supports biodiversity but that it’s out of date. She would work to carefully incentivize developers to keep trees. Meilleur’s family has turned their boulevard into a pollinator garden with bee turf, wildflowers and perennials.

Meilleur’s current work is mostly with First Nations, helping them to recover from the floods last fall (the atmospheric river event in November). But she says climate change-focused actions are “not a ticky box.”

“Those principles must be integrated into everything. Comox would benefit from this same clarity in its strategic vision. There are lots of best practices out there to draw from. There are not many council decisions that wouldn’t benefit from a climate change lens,” she said.

Meilleur believes that local governments need to talk about making “regenerative” actions and policies.

“Our environment is too degraded now so putting it back the same is no longer good enough. It has to be better than before and I think people are starting to get that now,” she said.

Food security is another of Meilleur’s key issues. She believes that community food security can be improved with urban agriculture bylaws.

“Comox made a start but it needs to be more robust to allow hens and front yard greenhouses. We need to make it easy for people to grow food and share it with neighbors. This builds community resilience,” she said.

Meilleur understands that local governments are just finding their feet in regard to reconciliation efforts and that current systems aren’t designed to support First Nations or other equity deserving groups. She thinks she can contribute by using her collaboration skills.

Government-to-government relations are now a big part of every local government’s planning and that “creates a significant paradigm shift for everyone.”

“What I mean is that we aren’t fighting over pieces of a pie, we’re trying to make the pie bigger for everyone. And when we put Indigenous people and other historically marginalized people at the centre of our work, we all benefit,” she said.

The town will be reviewing its Official Community Plan during the next four years and Meilleur would like to be part of that process. The current OCP was updated in 2011.

“The existing document is not visionary. It needs to be more inspirational and account for climate action as Courtenay has done with their OCP,” she said. “Perhaps we should include a citizens’ assembly in the process to engage as many people as possible.”

And finally, Meilleur would do what she can to support local businesses.

“At any given time, there are only about three days of supplies that people need on Vancouver Island and we have already experienced supply chain disruptions from the pandemic and the atmospheric river in November of last year,” she said. “Any type of natural or climate disaster that cuts off those supplies will be serious. Therefore, we need to shorten the supply chain and make more of what we need on the Island.”

 

The most misunderstood thing about Comox Town Council

In some local governments, Meilleur sees a lack of urgency and clarity of vision. And she doesn’t think the current system and the way local governments often work were designed for the complex problems of today.

“The public sees that it’s not working. They want it to be better,” she said. “We have to learn to disagree better and how to be of service to our community and to these times. I am running to be of service.”

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

WHERE AND WHEN TO VOTE

General Voting Day is Saturday, Oct. 15 for all local government positions.

Comox Valley Regional District

General Voting Day and advance voting take place at the CVRD building in Courtenay from 8 am to 8 pm.

Go to this link for General Voting Day locations in the three Electoral Areas.

Additional voting takes place on Oct. 6 from 9 am to 12 pm on Denman Island and on Oct. 6 from 2 pm to 5 pm on Hornby Island

Courtenay

Advance Voting begins on Wednesday October 5, 2022, 8 am to 8 pm at the Native Sons Hall, and again on Wednesday October 12, 2022, 8 am to 8 pm at the Florence Filberg Centre.

General Voting Day, Saturday, October 15, 2022, 8 am to 8 pm at the Queneesh Elementary School, and at the Florence Filberg Centre.

Comox

Advance voting begins Wednesday, October 5 from 8 a.m. – 8 p.m. at the Comox Community Centre, and on Saturday, October 8 from 10 a.m. – 2 p.m. at the Genoa Sail Building at Comox Marina, and again on Monday, October 10 from 10 a.m. – 2 p.m. at the Genoa Sail Building at Comox Marina, and on Wednesday, October 12 from 8 a.m. – 8 p.m. at the Comox Community Centre.

General Voting Day runs from 8 am to 8 pm on Oct. 15 at the Comox Community Centre.

Cumberland

All voting in the Village of Cumberland takes place from 8 am to 8 pm at the Cumberland Cultural Centre. Advance voting takes place on Oct. 5 and Oct. 12.

SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTER

Enter your email address to subscribe to the Decafnation newsletter.

More
The Mack Laing Trust: BC Supreme Court hears arguments in 40-year case

The Mack Laing Trust: BC Supreme Court hears arguments in 40-year case

Hamilton Mack Laing tends trees in his Nut Farm above Comox Bay in the early to mid 1900s

The Mack Laing Trust: BC Supreme Court hears arguments in 40-year case

By

The 40-year saga of an internationally famous naturalist and Comox Valley pioneer who left his waterfront property, possessions and money to the Town of Comox finally made it to the BC Supreme Court recently, where lawyers argued the legal technicalities of his Trust Agreement and his Last Will and Testament.

The the three-day proceedings in Courtroom 200 at the Courtenay Courthouse with Justice Jennifer A. Power presiding provided a stark contrast to the rich history and universal respect for the man, Hamilton Mack Laing, and his passion for the natural world and the biodiversity he found in the early 1920s along Comox Bay.

Instead, a lawyer for the Town of Comox and another for the BC Attorney General speculated on a broader meaning of certain words used in the Trust Agreement and other documents. They cited statues in municipal governance and jurisprudence that didn’t exist in 1973 when Mack Laing started making his gifts to the town or even in 1981 when he wrote his last wishes before he died in early 1982.

The lawyers hoped to convince Justice Power that despite misappropriating Laing’s money and misleading past council members, the Town of Comox should be allowed to demolish the man’s heritage home, Shakesides, and use his money for purposes that Laing had not explicitly envisioned.

They also spent a large portion of their time before Justice Power arguing that she should ignore most of the hundreds of pages of evidence and documentation submitted by the Mack Laing Heritage Society (The Society), an intervenor in this case, because they are “not relevant” to section 184 of the 2003 BC Community Charter.

They dismissed the numerous affidavits provided by The Society as “opinion and hearsay” that purport to describe Laing’s importance to the town’s history and the field of natural history generally and to prove that the terms of his gifts were crystal clear.

But something was missing in this cold, binary courtroom summarization of the legal fine points, which the lawyers so aptly boiled down to what was documented or not and which words were precise or vague and whether agreements made between 1973 and 1981 do or do not comport with a 2003 law. Absent from the discussion, except when The Society’s lawyer took the podium, was the context of the social-political-bureaucratic environment during which this 40-year travesty took place.

The Society’s lawyer did his best to paint that bigger picture. The Society believes that Justice Power, and anyone else masochistic enough to read through the mountain of public filings in this case, will discover the struggles of a lone female advocate for Laing’s wishes, the pursuit of personal agendas, the political strategies that were afoot and the unsavory means used to achieve them.

The Society believes Justice Power will learn that Laing was a good-hearted man, albeit naive about fickle town councils, who wanted his life’s achievements to live on and educate those who came after him and that the intention for his gifts to the people of Comox were clear and indisputable.

The Society’s lawyer said the Town of Comox had made its own mess and was now in a rush to clean it up. But, he argued, there is no good reason why, after 40 years, the town can’t wait for a thorough accounting of how much money should be in the Trust Fund and for an independent assessment of Shakesides’ viability by heritage building professionals.

After hearing from the town, the Attorney General and The Society, Justice Power gave no immediate ruling. Her decisions in this case could take weeks.

The Mack Laing saga is ultimately a story of how clever people can obfuscate the big picture using the detachment of legal proceedings and try to rewrite history to serve a modern agenda. It’s a cautionary tale about how municipal staff can lead a town council down an ethically wrong path and how a majority of them willingly follow it.

The case puts an exclamation point on the importance of electing mayors and council members who believe in playing by the rules. In other words, serious public servants who are determined to fully understand the issues before them and who refuse to take the lazy route of blindly accepting staff recommendations.

But that’s just our opinion.

What follows now is a brief summary of the arguments heard by Justice Power.

 

WHAT THE TOWN AND ATTORNEY GENERAL SAID

The BC Attorney General, represented by Sointula Kirkpatrick, and the Town represented by Mike Moll, argued that Laing had made two separate trusts. In the first one in 1973, the Park Trust, Laing gifted his property including the Shakesides house. In the second in 1981 via his Last Will and Testament, the Trust, Laing left the residue of his estate – money and possessions – to the town.

The lawyers said only the 1981 trust was before the court. That argument, if accepted by Justice Power, means that the Shakesides house was given to the town without conditions in the earlier Parks Trust and was the town’s property to do with as it pleased. The only issue before the court was whether the later Trust funds could be spent to construct a viewing platform.

“It has been 40 years since he made his bequest. Shakesides was never suitable to be a museum and the Trust Funds were and are not sufficient to make it one,” Kirkpatrick told the court.

She said further that “most of The Society’s evidence is not relevant to this court’s determination under Section 184 of the Community Charter.” And she went on to argue details of general trust law principles.

At that point, Justice Power stopped the proceedings to address the gallery, comprising only members of The Society. Justice Power said that despite the AG lawyer’s opinion of The Society’s evidence, only she would determine its relevance.

In regards to the comprehensive plan prepared by The Society and two dozen community volunteers to restore Shakesides and convert it to a natural history museum, Kirkpatrick said their proposal was “beyond the scope of this proceeding and has no basis in law.”

She concluded that the town’s proposal to construct a “Nature Park Platform can accommodate the K‘omoks First Nations’ concern about disturbance to the Great Comox Midden on which Shakesides is located, without further delay or unnecessary litigation.”

She said Mack Laing’s charitable intentions should be carried out through the building of the platform and she asked the court to “grant the variation sought on the conditions proposed by the Attorney General and to which the Town agrees.”

The town’s lawyer, Mike Moll said, “The Town is applying to vary the Trust because the Town’s Council now considers the terms of the Trust to no longer be in the best interests of the Town. The Town says that the Nature Park Platform containing natural history education panels will better further both the intention of the will-maker and the best interests of the Town.’

 

WHAT THE SOCIETY SAID

The Mack Laing Heritage Society, represented by Kevin Simonett of Campbell River, argued that “In breaching its obligations as trustee and allowing waste and neglect of the culturally valuable and irreplaceable trust object (Shakesides), Comox has manufactured the very crisis it now claims as justification to vary the trust.

“Comox does not come before the court with clean hands and is the author of a delay of several decades.”

Simonett went to say that after 40 years of the town’s financial mismanagement and dereliction of trustee obligations and fiduciary duty – “to which Comox has essentially admitted” – a forensic accounting of the trust funds and an independent assessment is required to ascertain the true financial health and structural integrity of Shakesides.

“Comox offers no explanation as to why they cannot wait for such forensic auditing
and physical inspection to be completed. Instead, they insist on immediate
demolition of a culturally valuable and historic home to be replaced with little more than a concrete slab,” he told the court.

Simonett argued that the town’s conclusion that Shakesides is unsuitable for use as a museum was “a foregone conclusion.” Since the town received Laing’s gifts, “the town has selectively sought out informal information tending to confirm that conclusion, rather than carrying out proper due diligence and obtaining expert opinions.”

He detailed how a town executive ignored the misspending of Laing’s money, stacked an advisory committee to get the result he wanted and then misled council members to make decisions based on a non-existent Park Plan and a flawed process designed to achieve personal and political purposes.

He argued that there was only one trust, not two, which Laing continued to amend through the period from 1973 to 1981.

“By way of gift in his last will and testament, the (Laing) carried out the Settlement upon the Park Trust; his intent was to add the residue of his estate to the trust corpus established under the Park Trust, on the terms set out in the instrument of gift. The Town in its capacity as Trustee had notice of these terms, and indeed had a hand in negotiating them, and accepted these terms when it accepted the funds forming the Settlement upon the Park Trust,” Simonett said.

Simonett told Justice Power that the town and the AG have provided evidence, “only on the putative cost-effectiveness of varying the Park Trust to remove Shakesides, and none as to the superiority per se of the viewing platform. It is the Intervenor’s position that the relative cost-effectiveness of the competing visions for Mack Laing Park has not been determined, due to the protracted intransigence of the town.”

 

SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTER

Enter your email address to subscribe to the Decafnation newsletter.

More

MLHS issues letter of thanks to Comox Council

Mack Laing Heritage Society archive photo By George Le Masurier he Mack Laing Heritage Society this morning issued an open letter to the Town of Comox mayor and council. Here is their letter: We, the Mack Laing...

Court will allow opposing evidence in Mack Laing case

A BC Supreme Court has granted the Mack Laing Heritage Society intervenor status in the Town of Comox’s application to alter the naturalist’s public trust. MLHS hopes the new council is open to out-of-court discussions

Town’s Mack Laing “hub” aims to influence court

The timing of the Tow of Como’x new information hub about Mack Laing seems to indicate that it will function mostly to justify the town’s controversial decision to have the terms of the Mack Laing Trust altered by the B.C. Supreme Court and to report on the outcome of the case.

Questions the Town of Comox doesn’t want asked in court

Why is the Town of Comox fighting so hard and spending so much money on lawyers to keep the Mack Laing Heritage Society from presenting evidence during a BC Supreme Court trial to decide whether the town can vary the terms of the famous ornithologist’s financial gifts in trust to municipality?

Supreme Court rules in favor of Mack Laing Heritage Society

The Mack Laing Heritage Society has won a major legal ruling in its battle to force the Town of Comox to honor trust agreements with the famous naturalist. It’s the first step in a case that will decide the future of Laing’s iconic home and clarify the status of his trust agreements.

Shakesides supporters encouraged, hearing adjourned

A B.C. Supreme Court hearing scheduled for this morning (March 15) to determine whether to grant standing to the Mack Laing Heritage Society (MLHS) in the Town of Comox’s application to vary one of the famous ornithologis’s trusts has been adjourned until April. But Shakesides supporters left the court session encouraged.

Nicole Minions: New Comox mayor relieved of campaigning, prepares for shifting role

Nicole Minions: New Comox mayor relieved of campaigning, prepares for shifting role

Nicole Minions, unopposed for mayor of Comox, will win the seat by acclamation. She is already focusing on her new role.

Nicole Minions: New Comox mayor relieved of campaigning, prepares for shifting role

By

Nicole Minions, a one-term council member, will become the new mayor of the Town of Comox. At the filing deadline on Friday, Minions was the only candidate to file for the mayoralty. She will win the election by acclamation.

Minions sat down with Decafnation early last week to discuss her first term as a councillor and, if re-elected on Oct. 15, what she would focus on in the next four years. We met again on Saturday to discuss her new role as mayor.

It’s interesting to note that Minions had told us nearly two weeks ago that she was considering a challenge to incumbent Russ Arnott for mayor but had not come to a final decision. She said that she would certainly run if Arnott chose to step down.

Minions had already decided and turned in her papers for the mayoralty when Arnott announced on Facebook Thursday night that he was not running. Even so, she told Decafnation, she had expected another challenger that did not materialize.

Now, instead of campaigning for a council seat, the under-40 mayor is shifting toward her new role as the person responsible for facilitating a functional seven-member council.

“But that doesn’t change my priorities or beliefs,” she told us. “That’s still who I am.”

In the near term, Minions said she would focus on helping to increase voter turnout. Local government elections usually see a lower percentage of potential voters than provincial or federal elections.

She also plans to meet with all 11 candidates for the six council seats up for grabs.

She won’t, however, be formally endorsing any candidates. Minions says that would be counterintuitive to her new role. But she will be attending some campaign events.

One of the themes of her mayoralty will be creating open communications, which she believes will help the new combination of seven council members to coalesce as a group.

And early in her term, she plans an opportunity for the new council to set some clear strategic priorities.

“Right now, the work plan has about a thousand things on it,” she says. “We need to identify the two or three top priorities and create a well-organized flow chart.”

Minions would like to change how the Town of Comox is seen regionally and is considering how to advocate for that. She wants Comox Valley’s perception of Comox Council to be a fair representation of the actual council. And part of that, she says, is how information flows to and from the council.

Minions has already reached out to other Vancouver Island mayors for advice, including the mayor of Port Alberni, Shari Minions, who happens to be her sister-in-law.

 

INTERVIEW WITH NICOLE MINIONS

Before 4 pm last Friday, Nicole Minions was seeking a second term on the Comox Town Council. Now will be acclaimed as mayor.

She was one of four under-35-year-old candidates elected in 2018. Minions has 10 years of experience in the banking industry and has worked in the nonprofit sector including as Executive Director of SOS Children’s Village in Vancouver.

She moved to Comox with her two children nine years ago as a buyer’s agent and Realtor and has since co-founded a real estate company called 2.5 Percent Just Real Estate Inc. in downtown Comox.

 

Why should voters re-elect you?

Minions says she is her own hardest critic.

“I’ve learned in the last years that it is a person’s character and values that make a good councillor, regardless of their platform or their community engagement,” she told Decafnation.

She says a councillor has to be predictable, but open-minded, “so the public can trust or depend on how you will vote. You must stay true to your genuine values.”

Minions says council members need to attend the meetings fully prepared, which means having read through all the material you get with four days’ notice. And you have to be accessible to all people in the community equally because you represent all individuals, businesses and societies.

“I show up as a conscientious councillor in all of these ways and would like the opportunity to do so this next term,” she said.

Minions ran on a variety of issues, including affordable housing, banning single-use plastics and increasing or fostering youth engagement.“

And I did focus on these issues,” she said. “I delivered on housing as we have more rental and multi-family townhome units today and more infill within the current footprint, which addresses our two hardest challenges today: environment and social justice in our society and community.”

Council passed her motion to ban plastic bags, but the province struck down all municipal bans in BC.

“And then the pandemic changed everything. But I got the conversation going,” she said, adding that other communities have adopted volunteer bans despite the province’s action, “so it’s something to look at.”

Minions’ first four years on the council were full of disruptions, but she voted true to what she said and says, “nobody should be surprised by my record.”

“On the Mack Laing issue, Steph McGowan and I stood on our principles and voted to keep trying to negotiate with those opposed to the town’s plan. We didn’t cave to the pressure,” she said.

Minions understands that 90 percent of a councillor’s job is to ensure the town delivers excellent core services. But, she says, that other 10 percent is important, too.

“We have to always be looking for opportunities that don’t detract from our core services. We can apply lenses of fiscal responsibility, environment, equality and reconciliations, as examples, to every decision that is made at our Town Hall. There is room to clearly articulate where we are going, and leaving no one behind.”

 

What are some of your key accomplishments?

Minions championed the idea of holding a climate change open house this year. “We communicated where we are and what the future looks like. We listened to the climate-focused actions the public wants. Now, we need to keep this conversation going.”

She considers the 695 Aspen development near Quality Foods as an accomplishment even though neighbors opposed it. The town got 208 new rental units, five at below market rate in partnership with M’akola Housing Society and 28 new daycare spaces with the help of a provincial grant.

“At some point, we were discussing the mix of rentals versus sales units and I was a loud voice to keep the much-needed rental units. I may work in real estate but I truly value putting what our community needs first in every decision,” she said.

The developer wanted to sell all of the Aspen units to take advantage of rising prices, but “I fought hard against that on the principle that we should hold developers accountable to do what they promised and agreed to do.”

Council revised the Tree Retention Bylaw to increase tree retention from 25 percent to 30 percent, but she says, “There’s still work to be done.”

“It’s called a retention bylaw, but in reality, developers can achieve the percentage goal by retention or replanting,” she said. “I’d like to revisit this bylaw.”

Minions recognizes that big issues, such as trees and affordable housing contributions, affect planning and development and that they “move the market in the cost to develop, but they’re for the common good.”

Minions is proud that Comox Council was the first in the Comox Valley to enact the new BC Step Code in 2019-2021, which will have an impact on improving the energy efficiencies of new construction.

 

Goals for the next four years

Minnions’ number one goal for the next term is to focus on emergency planning given the rapidly changing climate and the adaptations that will be necessary – “We can expect floods, heat domes and someday an earthquake,” she says. 

She thinks it would be wise to break emergency planning down by neighborhoods. Minions envisions 10 zones (neighborhoods) that each identify resources available to people in those areas.

“For example, does a doctor or other medical professionals live in the zone? Where is a Satellite radio, emergency planning, access to water in the neighborhood?” she said. “Emergency planning is a provincial issue but the Comox demographic requires preparedness at the town level. Breaking it down to neighborhoods is the natural place to start.”

She wants to explore the formation of a Housing Advisory Committee. The town has a small planning department, she says, so a committee could help the council parse technical reports and review design aspects of applications.

“I plan to explore grant funding for a staff housing coordinator position because there’s not a lot of extra room in our budget for anything beyond core services,” she said. “Comox has the highest percentage of single-family homes in the Comox Valley. Given the state of things, it’s important to think outside of the box.

“The status quo is not acceptable any longer,” she said.

The town needs more recreation opportunities for teens in her view. That’s one of the lessons coming out of the pandemic, she says, which presented particular challenges for teens.

“I would like us to build a pump track because there’s a close enough skateboard park near Isfeld school. And it wouldn’t be difficult for the Comox Rec Center to develop a drop-in youth center. Maybe add some built-in games in our parks, like a chessboard.” These ideas are contained in the Youth Activity Report presented to the council last year.

“I would argue that recreation is a core service.”  

Minions believes that reconciliation with K’omoks First Nation should be a focus for our community.

“There’s relationship-building work we can do with Chief Rempel and the council on how we show up as a good neighbour, consult regularly and acknowledge our history. There are a lot of partnerships happening around the CVRD and I think we have a lot to listen and learn about as we move forward together,” she said.

 

What is most misunderstood about the Council Town Council?

Minions believes that no council member intentionally makes a bad decision.

“They are all serving our constituencies in their own way and are influenced one way or another by the people they talk to,” she said. “But the public shouldn’t lump the whole council and mayor together.”

She recognizes that there is public curiosity about how decisions are made and the background behind them. There’s a gap, she says, between the reasons behind decisions and the public perceptions of what those reasons are.

“It would help if there was less group speculation and misinformation in social media dialogue and more one-on-one conversations with council members,” she said. “I prefer to respond and listen to people who connect directly. Accountability and transparency is a two-way engagement.”

She says the current council hasn’t always agreed on everything, “but we have been respectful and functional with each other a majority of the time.”

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

WHERE AND WHEN TO VOTE

General Voting Day is Saturday, Oct. 15 for all local government positions.

Comox Valley Regional District

General Voting Day and advance voting take place at the CVRD building in Courtenay from 8 am to 8 pm.

Go to this link for General Voting Day locations in the three Electoral Areas.

Additional voting takes place on Oct. 6 from 9 am to 12 pm on Denman Island and on Oct. 6 from 2 pm to 5 pm on Hornby Island

Courtenay

Advance Voting begins on Wednesday October 5, 2022, 8 am to 8 pm at the Native Sons Hall, and again on Wednesday October 12, 2022, 8 am to 8 pm at the Florence Filberg Centre.

General Voting Day, Saturday, October 15, 2022, 8 am to 8 pm at the Queneesh Elementary School, and at the Florence Filberg Centre.

Comox

Advance voting begins Wednesday, October 5 from 8 a.m. – 8 p.m. at the Comox Community Centre, and on Saturday, October 8 from 10 a.m. – 2 p.m. at the Genoa Sail Building at Comox Marina, and again on Monday, October 10 from 10 a.m. – 2 p.m. at the Genoa Sail Building at Comox Marina, and on Wednesday, October 12 from 8 a.m. – 8 p.m. at the Comox Community Centre.

General Voting Day runs from 8 am to 8 pm on Oct. 15 at the Comox Community Centre.

Cumberland

All voting in the Village of Cumberland takes place from 8 am to 8 pm at the Cumberland Cultural Centre. Advance voting takes place on Oct. 5 and Oct. 12.

 

 

SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTER

Enter your email address to subscribe to the Decafnation newsletter.

More
Mack Laing goes to court today and, have spies infiltrated local government?

Mack Laing goes to court today and, have spies infiltrated local government?

Hamilton Mack Laing, a man who gave his house, property, many possessions and money to the Town of Comox, who took it and then snubbed him.

Mack Laing goes to court today and, have spies infiltrated local government?

By

It’s a shame the Town of Comox waited almost four years before finally taking their petition back to the BC Supreme Court today (Wednesday, Sept. 7) to vary the town’s trust agreement with Hamilton Mack Laing to tear down his heritage house and spend the money he gifted for purposes other than his original intentions.

The Town Council could have collaborated to find a win-win with the Mack Laing Heritage Society and those community members who have volunteered to preserve some form of the house, called Shakesides. Instead, the Town Council stopped listening.

And they also stopped going to court for the permissions they need.

The court dates this week fall just 37 days before the 2022 municipal election, making it unlikely the Justice hearing arguments will rule before voters go to the polls. Win or lose, we would have preferred that those incumbents seeking reelection had to account for their voting record on this issue.

As an intervenor, the Mack Laing Heritage Society has asked the court in public filings to dismiss the town’s application to vary the trust, and instead order a forensic accounting of the Trust Fund, an independent assessment of the viability of the Shakesides structure and to direct the town to include the rental income it derived from Shakesides into the trust fund or a related separate fund.

“In breaching its obligations as trustee and allowing waste and neglect of the culturally valuable and irreplaceable trust object (Shakesides), Comox has manufactured the very crisis it now claims as justification to vary the trust; Comox does not come before the court with clean hands and is the author of a delay of several decades,” the society says in its written submission.

The society goes on to assert that the town has “willfully ignored all evidence, offers of assistance and reports that do not contemplate the demolition of Shakesides, or that require a proper accounting of the Trust Fund.”

If the court agrees with the MLHS and orders an accounting and structural assessment before ruling on the town’s application, it could be another year before the matter is finally settled.

Of course, the Town of Comox has had about 40 years to atone for their neglect, so what’s another dozen months?

What’s important for this election is that only one incumbent candidate in the race for Town Council, Nicole Minions, had the ethical integrity to vote against proceeding with this petition and for continued collaboration. Stephanie McGown voted with Minions, but she is not likely to seek office in Comox this year.

Jonathan Kerr no doubt would have joined those two in doing the right thing, but he only joined the council nine months ago.

Stay tuned, as Decafnation will file additional reports on the court case later in the week.

 

Candidates coming out of the woodwork

Former Courtenay mayor Starr Winchester has filed again for City Council, and so has Deana Simkin. They both ran in 2018 and missed the cut by about 10 percent. Brennan Day, who failed to get elected provincially, is now trying local government again. He fell short by nearly seven percent of the vote last time. Nobody has filed for mayor except perennial candidate Erik Eriksson.

Incumbent Arzeena Hamir will have at least two challengers in Area B, Richard Hardy and Keith Stevens. And Tamara Meggitt will challenge incumbent Daniel Arbour in Area A.

Big news, Don Davis has filed again in Comox, as he has every election since, well, forever.

Bad news, Courtenay resident Peter Gibson has filed in Comox. The last time a Courtenay resident filed in Comox, to our knowledge, was when former Comox councillor Tom Grant moved to Crown Isle and tried to keep a seat in Comox. That ended badly as it should have and as it should again.

 

American political creep

The four or five people who are behind the vacuous website, Comox Valley Mainstream, are either rebranding themselves or they’ve gained partners.

A new anonymous website has cropped up called Take Back Comox Valley. Take back from whom, we wonder? The people who built a plant so we wouldn’t have regular boil water advisories? The people who have kept governments going during the pandemic and kept taxes reasonable while doing it?

The people who have taken the backroom dealing out of local politics and put their work transparently into formal policies to deal fairly and consistently with everyone concerned?

It seems these folks are dragging a little right-wing conspiracy tendency across the southern border. Even their name sounds a little like Make America Great Again.

Based on their website, the Taker Backers are going after some group they won’t name that wants to “to stop the expansion of our business community, disrupt our industries, and defund our police.” Holy Moly, who are those evil people?

Frankly, I haven’t heard anybody around here calling to defund the police. Anyway, wouldn’t that be the RCMP? Good luck with that.

And what industry is being disrupted? Even if we stop cutting old-growth timber, the logging industry will remain robust. The Alberta oil industry? Whether the Comox Valley allows 1,000 new gas stations or zero, it won’t send chills down anybody’s spine in Calgary.

But, these concerned citizens claim a righteous fight, “to keep American money and foreign activists out of our local politics.” That’s right, American billionaires are so concerned with issues like garbage and kitchen waste pickup in the rural areas that they are paying undocumented secret agents to infiltrate our local governments.

Sorry, Taker Backers. When you try to get QAnon-style conspiracy thinking going outside the American South, it just doesn’t roll so easily as it does in Alabama.

 

Heads in the sand

There is always a small element of the public that wants our municipal councillors to do nothing more than fill potholes and make the toilets flush. They may be the same people that want schools to do no more than teach students to read, write and add numbers.

The basics are important in every aspect of life but don’t people want, even demand a quality of life that goes far beyond that? Where would we be without music and art in our lives? Without hobbies? Parks and trails? Access to all the things that people are passionate about? Visionary thinking?

Those aren’t the basics, but they enrich our basic lives and in the Comox Valley it may be the single most common reason that people live here.

Councillors who only think about sewers and potholes won’t lead us toward a more vibrant, interesting and rewarding community. Such stunted thinking will do the opposite. And who wants to live in a town without any charm or soul?

 

SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTER

Enter your email address to subscribe to the Decafnation newsletter.

More

Our recommendations in the 2022 Comox Valley local government elections

Decafnation announces its list of preferred candidates in this year’s local government elections and for the first time we identify candidates that we think show promise and provide our reasons for not endorsing the other candidates. Our endorsements fall on the first day of voting at advance polls