Photo Caption
Courtenay challengers finally clam up about city finances
A fter watching the City of Courtenay all-candidates event on Oct. 1, one thought kept rattling my already rattled brain: Who are these people?
They didn’t sound like the same 17 council challengers who have been wailing on and on about property taxes, capital spending and the city’s debt for months before the municipal election campaign began two weeks ago.
Granted, these challengers and their sometimes manic followers did most of their wailing on the local Facebook politics pages, where everybody wails. It’s a thing. I wailed just having to read through all that wailing.
Anyway, those wailing people seem to have gone missing. My hearing gets worse every year, but I swear that nobody wailed about ‘out-of-control-spending’’ when they got to a public forum. Wailing is apparently easier to do while alone typing on computer keyboard.
Yes, there were a few rough and misinformed allusions to financial matters. Candidate Kam Singhania, for example, stood up to wave some papers around and wailed about “deficits,” apparently not knowing that Courtenay has never run a deficit because, by provincial law, it is forbidden to do so.
John Dacombe, who talks about finances a lot and promises to lower your property taxes, said he could save $1-$3 million by speeding up the installation of water meters, a plan the city had already considered and found to be more expensive.
Dick Clancy once again offered up some muddled math about compounding interest rates that I didn’t understand and that a finance industry person told me later didn’t make sense.
Dave Mellin wailed quixotically about spending $32 million on the outdoor pool at Lewis Park, even though the incumbent council members have made it clear the project is a no-go for the city, unless the whole region agrees to help pick up the tab.
Mayoral candidate Manno Theos seemed to have forgotten all about his criticism of the Sixth Street “bridge to nowhere.” He never mentioned it. Maybe he changed his mind. Again.
Where were the City Council challengers who have been so critical of Courtenay’s financial management? We expected them to show up with lock-down plans to reduce expenses, spend less and lower taxes.
Instead, what I heard from the challengers were proposals for even more wildly expensive projects.
Both former council member Erik Eriksson and first-time hopeful Dick Clancy proposed building a dam on the Cruikshank River to create another water reservoir. That may be a good idea, but it sent my financial advisor’s eyeballs spinning dollar signs like a slot machine.
Another candidate wailed about unhoused people littering the downtown and proposed expanding the city’s contract with the RCMP to dispatch officers 24/7 to the city’s streets. To do what, he didn’t specify. But as policing costs are already one of the city’s largest single expenses, this would potentially double or triple those costs.
Mayoral candidate Manno Theos must really love bridges. In 2019, he enthusiastically pumped council to build the Sixth Street bridge. In 2026, he decided attacking the bridge would help his campaign , hoping everybody had forgotten about 2019. Wrong!
On Thursday, he pumped for yet another bridge: twining the 17th St. bridge, or “at least start taking a look at it,” he beamed, without a hint of irony in his voice.
‘Start taking a look?’ The council and city staff have looked at how to improve traffic on the bridge for years, but they keep bumping into a rather large problem: The province owns it. The City of Courtenay has no authority or responsibility over that bridge.
But if Manno could build it, just imagine what that would cost.
Later, mayoral candidate Bob Wells pointed out that twinning a drawbridge would be so expensive that a grant request for it had already been turned down by a federal government willing to spend $43 billion to twin a pipeline across British Columbia.
Aside from these lowlights, all of the candidates responded with good answers to the Chamber of Commerce’s questions. Many of them did well enough to increase their chances of finishing at the top in a crowded 19-horse race.
But what happened to the candidates who for months had wailed without evidence about the city’s sky high property taxes, out-of-control spending, unsustainable debt and overall terrible financial management? Where did they go?
I have no idea. But I sure don’t miss ‘em.
ADVANCE VOTING DAYS
AND TIMES
COURTENAY
Wednesday, October 7 — 8 a.m. to 8 p.m. — Florence Filberg Centre
Wednesday, October 14 — 8 a.m. to 8 p.m. — Florence Filberg Centre
CV REGIONAL DISTRICT
Wednesday, October 7– 8 am to 8 pm — Comox Valley Regional District Civic Room
Thursday, October 8 — 9 am to 12 pm — Denman Activity Centre
Thursday, October 8 — 3 to 6 pm — ornby Island New Horizons Hall
Wednesday, October 14 — 8 am to 8 pm Comox Valley Regional District Civic Room
COMOX
Wednesday, October 7 — 8 a.m. – 8 p.m. — Comox Community Centre
Saturday, October — 10 a.m. – 2 p.m. — Genoa Sail Building at Comox Marina
Monday, October 12 — 10 a.m. – 2 p.m. — Genoa Sail Building at Comox Marina
Wednesday, October 14 — 8 a.m. – 8 p.m. — Comox Community Centre
CUMBERLAND
Wednesday, October 7 – 8:00 a.m. to 8:00 p.m. — Cultural Centre
Wednesday, October 14 — 8:00 a.m. to 8:00 p.m. — Cultural Centre
Saturday, October 17 — 8:00 a.m. to 8:00 p.m. –Cultural Centre
SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTER
THE WEEK: Hamir to chair CVRD – Confusion at City Council – City crime down
Violent crime dropped 18 percent over last year in Courtenay, according to the RCMP’s second quarterly report. This week’s City Council meeting got bogged down with procedural missteps and a verbal attack in the gallery. CVRD directors elect Arzeena Hamir as chair of the board and there’s good news and bad news.
The “Seven-Day Building Permit Rule” in Comox, a flurry of motions in Courtenay
A Comox Valley developer has reportedly met the Seven-Day Rule for a building permit in Comox, most likely changing the Town Council’s consideration of downzoning the site. In Courtenay, notices of motion include a review of city operations, a deputy mayor position and freezing of council salaries for two years.
The Week: We’ve got the data! A look ahead at busy councils, and Good/Bad news
Any human with a computer has access to all the local government financial data they could ever want … and more. Unless you’re a financial statement nerd and need the real thing, check out our spreadsheets today that play your government’s greatest hits. Plus, tension-packed council meetings expected in Comox and Courtenay.
To frame the current zoning conflict in Comox about one property minimizes the democratic process
The whole timeline and background story about how the Town of Comox got into conflict with the owner of 1890 Comox Avenue is long and complicated, but the essence of the dispute is much simpler: the community at large does not want what this developer is offering and they couldn’t have made that point more clear than the Oct. 17 election results
The Week: The sun still rises every morning, just a lot later than usual, and other stuff
The Week looks at the time change chaos created by former BC Premier John Horgan’s sketchy poll and asks, “Why?” And then we turn to a candidate who this week announced her candidacy for the 2029 federal election and ask, “Why?” Finally we take a deeper dive into hospital boards with Doug Hillian and throw out some data about data centers
Inaugural meeting: Comox Council considers a six-storey project, Mayor Minions’s address
The Town of Comox held its inaugural council meeting Wednesday night so new councillors could take the oath of office and Mayor Nicole Minions could deliver her State of the Town address. But unlike traditional inaugural meetings, this one required the new council to address a development project approved by the previous council that conflicts with the election mandate opposed to six-storey buildings in the downtown core.
Courtenay City Council majority overrules new Mayor Theos’s appointments
Manno Theos may have won the Courtenay mayor’s office but he lost the first battle with the City Council this week, as four councillors objected to his proposed appointments to the regional district board and other assignments. Instead, the council majority passed their own list of appointments, leaving Theos off the CVRD board.
Mayor Brown gets emotional, says the village inspires her even on the hardest days
Mayor Vickey Brown and four Village Council members were sworn into office Monday night and accepted appointment to various boards and committees. In her inaugural address Brown acknowledged the importance of provincial funding and asked the community to leave the campaign behind and now focus on collaboration and team-building.
The Week: Manno’s speech, buying beds in CR, high five for Johns and the bird for Gunn
‘The Week’ is back — a weekly commentary on whatever comes our way. This week, a demo inaugural speech for new Mayor Manno Theos, how Comox Valley taxpayers are funding new long-term care beds in Campbell River, imagining Josie Osborne as the new BC NDP party leader and a bunch of other stuff.
Will Cole-Hamilton bucks the trend, flips Courtenay Comox riding to NDP
More than four thousand fewer Green Party voters showed up this year and incumbent Conservative MLA Brennan Day lost 787 votes as the NDP won in Courtenay-Comox by about a three percent margin. The ‘blue wave’ was strong across the province, however, taking 64 of the 93 seats in the BC Legislature
Thanks for plugging my pitch for implementing universal volumetric water metering, George. Unfortunately, you failed to mention that a five-year implementation (versus 12 years) means an extra seven years of saving at least $1M/year on bulk water sales, which means significant cost savings for City taxpayers. And that doesn’t even consider a pricing structure that more strongly incentivizes below average water use.
Also, do you really think we will have enough water in 2039, considering summer usage is going up at double population growth at the same time as glacier melt, snowpack, and summer rains are rapidly declining?
Fiscal restraint and environmental sustainability aren’t mutually exclusive, George.