Photo Caption
Overwhelmed by so many candidates? Just vote for the ones you know and like
B y the end of next week, Comox Valley residents will know who is officially running for local government offices in our three municipalities, the three regional electoral areas, School District 71 and the Islands Trust.
In the last municipal elections of 2022, there were a total of 57 candidates seeking the 31 local elected offices – seven in Courtenay and Comox, five in Cumberland, seven on the school board, three regional district area representatives and two for the Denman/Hornby Island trust area.
That’s a lot of candidates for voters in each voting jurisdiction to assess. In 2022, there were 14 candidates seeking the seven School District 71 positions alone, and another 18 for Courtenay City Council.
For many Valley residents, it’s just too much work and too confusing to gather the necessary information to make thoughtful selections. It could partly explain why only 30 percent of eligible voters turn out for local government elections.
With no single source of information about each individual candidate – such as comprehensive news media coverage – some eligible voters don’t bother casting a ballot. Others rely on conversations with their friends and neighbors.
Perhaps the best advice for voters is the simplest: You do not have to vote for candidates to fill all the vacant seats.
In response to last week’s pre-election article in Decafnation, subscriber Dede Fitton expressed this wide-spread frustration.
“To be serious, I live in Courtenay and I don’t know how any voter can sort through the “debates” on local (social media) forums. I’d like to make casting an informed vote easier but damned if I can figure out how.
“I think I should keep an open mind about new candidates. And a critical look at present council members. Now, how do I do that? I don’t follow council meetings.
I also know that most of a council member’s job is performed on committees and in the community, not at the public meeting.
“I wish there were criteria for candidates. Even more, I wish there were criteria for voters! (Tongue firmly in cheek).”
Ms. Fitton has identified the main obstacle facing Valley residents seeking factual information about individual candidates: Absent robust election coverage in the Comox Valley Record or the local radio stations’ news websites, people often resort to the Facebook pages devoted to local municipal politics.
But that almost never helps because although some people try to post factual information, they are usually overrun by paid trolls, bots and people hiding behind fake names. The pages are dominated by people who really just want to rant about one thing or another without adding anything useful to the conversation.
For example, when incumbent Courtenay Councilor Wendy Morin recently announced she is running again, her post was greeted with vile comments. Mark Jackson wrote, “No fing way. 18% tax increase a few years back cause (sic) of her. Sooner vote for a dog.” Jonny Valentine wrote, “We need to clean all these usless (sic) politicians out of city hall. Not voting for this chick for sure.”
Both Jackson and Valentine appear to be fake names on empty FB accounts. They might be bots or trolls paid by organizations determined to defeat forward-thinking council candidates.
There are only two elector organizations registered for the Comox Valley with Elections BC. One is the Conservative Electors Association run by David Denhoff, of North Vancouver, and the other is ParentsVoice BC, run by Marc Vella, of Langley.
ParentsVoice BC is a new BC party pushing school board candidates with anti-vaxx and conspiratorial views, per CBC news. Their slogan “Take Back Our Schools” translates to opposing education programs on health, racism, gender and sexuality.
For these reasons, sitting council members, school trustees and mayors generally avoid engaging in social media frenzies. It’s unfortunate, because without these online harassments and personal attacks, people could be getting factual information directly from their local government representatives.
So, how should voters assess this year’s candidates?
Perhaps the best advice for voters is the simplest: You do not have to vote for candidates to fill all the vacant seats.
If you have found a few candidates that you believe will represent you well, just vote for them. Period. You already have all the information you need to cast a thoughtful ballot.
It’s not necessary to fill the ballot with six council members plus the mayor. Just show up and cast a vote for the two or three or four who seem capable. Voting for only three or four candidates makes a perfectly valid ballot.
For many, the overwhelming part is getting a grasp on every candidate instead of just identifying a few worthy of support.
To help people do that, the Comox Valley Chamber of Commerce has scheduled three distinct candidate forums in late September.
– A forum for Cumberland candidates at 5:30 pm on Monday, Sept. 21 at the Cumberland Cultural Centre location.
– A forum for Comox candidates at 5:30 pm on Monday, Sept. 28 at the Comox Legion.
– A final forum for Courtenay candidates at 5:30 pm on Thursday, Oct. 1 at the North Island College Stan Hagen Theatre.
The Comox Valley Social Planning Society will also host an all-candidates forum specifically on substance abuse strategies at 5:00 pm on Tuesday, Sept. 22 at the Westerly Best Western Hotel in Courtenay. Candidates are being invited to meet the public starting at 4:00 pm.
There are rumours that Project Watershed and the NIC student union may hold candidate forums. In the past, there have been election events at Gladstones Brewing Co. in Courtenay and at some of the senior assisted living facilities.
That’s not much, but maybe the Record newspaper will engage more deeply during this election cycle. And Decafnation readers can read our upcoming Candidate Survey to compare individual responses.
WHO HAS OFFICIALLY FILED FOR OFFICE
Here’s a current list of who has filed or declared to run for local government positions this year. Nominations will close Sept. 11. For an updated list, see our separate post, which is updated several times every day.
COURTENAY
Bob Wells — Mayor, incumbent
Will Cole-Hamilton — Council, incumbent
Wendy Morin — Council, incumbent
David Frisch — Council, incumbent
Evan Jolicoeur — Council, incumbent
Manno Theos — Mayor
Dick Clancy — Council
Phil Adams — Council
Guancarlo “Benny” Benvenuti — Council
Rosanna Chamberlin — Council
Erik Eriksson — Council
CUMBERLAND
Troy Therrien — Council, incumbent
Vicky Brown — Mayor, incumbent
Nick Ward –Counmcil, incumbent
TOWN OF COMOX
Nicole Minions — Mayor, incumbent
CVRD ELECTORAL AREAS
Daniel Arbour — Electoral Area A, incumbent
Rich Hardy, Electoral Area B, incumbent
Arzeena Hamir — Electoral Area B
Ariel Becherer — Electoral Area C
Norman McPhail – Electoral Area C
ISLANDS TRUST
Sam Borthwick — Denman, incumbent
Perri Gorrara — Denman
SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTER
The City of Courtenay has chopped its total debt in half from 2012 to 2026
Here’s yet another way to understand the City of Courtenay’s financial management. The incumbent council has cut the the city’s total debt in half since 2012 and reduced its debt per capital by 64.7 percent during the same period. That’s fewer tax dollars spent on debt payments.
Provincial general election feels imminent — will the writ drop this week?
There are lots of signs pointing to Premier David Ebby calling for a BC general election as early as later this week. MLA Brennan Day will make an announcement in the next few days about whether he’ll run as an independent. And Courtenay Councillor Will Cole-Hamiltion withdrew his municipal re-election bid last Friday.
Courtenay’s controversial Sixth Street Bridge: Whose idea was it?
The idea for a pedestrian and cycling bridge at Sixth Street originated about 40 years ago and followed a roller coaster ride to completion. It might have never been built without the persuasive pleading from Downtown businesses in 2019. An effusive thumbs up from mayoral candidate Manno Theos might have helped, too.
Will Manno Theos win Courtenay in vote split? And are these candidates using AI?
What’s going on in this year’s local government elections? More candidates. More women candidates. Another possible vote split in Courtenay to favor the underdog. Many long-time veterans still hanging on. Fake social media posters and other trolls. And suspicions surfacing of plagiarism or AI use in candidate statements. Looks like a wild four-week ride. Buckle up!
Post-war attempt to ‘Run cities like a business’ by allowing sprawl failed miserably
After WWII, municipalities across Canada tried a private sector trick to generate revenue, but expanding a city’s tax base by allowing urban sprawl merely traded small temporary cash gains for the ticking time bomb of unfunded infrastructure liabilities … and the tax bill is now overdue
Fact: Courtenay property tax burden equal or lower than most same-sized BC cities
New candidates trying unseat Courtenay City Council incumbents claim the city’s property taxes are too high. But province-wide data shows that the city’s tax burden is the same or lower than same-sized municipalities. And City Council is leading the province with innovative fiscal policies
Retiring Courtenay City Councillors recap years of experience
Doug Hillian and Melanie McCollum will not be seeking re-election this for the Courtenay City Council. Hillian retired after 17 years on council. McCollum served for eight years.
The FINAL candidates for the 2026 local elections
A list of candidates for the 2026 municipal elections
THIS WEEK: Election signs are everywhere; MLA Day joins the Findlay ship jumpers
Candidates for the Oct. 17 municipal elections start making it official next week. But it’s been obvious that the “unofficial” campaigns began on social media a long time ago. And MLA Brennan Day announces he’s jumping BC Conservative Party’s ship — but it was no difficult decision
“Liberal Rush” tricked voters in NDP ridings and exposed an electoral system flaw
Despite the positive big picture outcome, this election exposed a glaring vulnerability within our electoral system. And that vulnerability caused otherwise smart people to forget how our Canadian parliamentary system actually works. Namely: We do not have a proportional representation form of government. But there is a simple solution.
Welcome back George! Good to hear from you with your sound knowledge. You made an important point “you don’t need to vote for a full slate”
Do you know of any all candidates meetings for Areas A, B, C ??
Hi Heather — Candidates who have announced or filed for the rural areas at the time were listed in the sidebar to this article. We will update a new post dedicated to the candidate list daily.
Thank you for all this information, sooo appreciated!
Hi George,
Welcome back. Every four years.
What a place to live. Been present since 1947 , but not always here. Moved away to make a living and enjoyed so much that BC and Canada has to offer. Most do realize , Thankfully, our bountiful, beautifully natural places, parks, beaches and forests.
The blight on this community is the unfortunate folks who are hopelessly addicted and hang over publicly funded shopping carts on Cliff avenue and some parks. victims of the NDP policy on public drug use and immunity for deadly drug dealer who perpetuate the disorder and public tragedy.
Both the Provincial MLA and the local Mayor and Courtenay CAO say that it is the other level of government that are responsible.
In this election, ask local candidates on their views on how to move forward on the issue of hopeless addiction and disorder. I suggest this is number one issue here and most communities.
Thanks
Thank you George for the sound advice.
Given the volume of dis- and mis-information on FB, I call it Faeces Book.
Bring back Nipper’s Town Howl meeting. Consistently the largest all candidates meetings in the CV.
Back when politics was kind of fun.
Hello George and welcome back.
I notice that you missed Erik Eriksson on your list of Courtenay Council candidates. I only mention this because Erik unofficially stated his intentions 4 years ago and submitted his papers early.
It’s amazing that Comox Valley elections involve paid trolls and bots. Although I could make a pretty good guess, I’d like to know who’s footing the bill for them.
Hi Terry — The article identifies two organizations that have registered as Elector Organizations for the Comox Valley area. They can endorse candidates, receive campaign contributions, incur election expenses and must abide by the Campaign Financing Act rules for expense limits, contribution limits, election advertising rules and finance reporting rules. An additional organization called Comox Valley Insight has registered as a Third Party Advertising Sponsor, which can sponsor advertising not paid for by the candidate or an Elector Organization.
Thanks for providing such valuable and accurate information to voters in support of the upcoming municipal elections in the Comox Valley, George. Your strategy of people voting only for the candidates they know and trust will help a lot of voters cast ballots that elect competent, well-intentioned representatives.
In the absence of thorough, hard-hitting coverage by local media, all-candidates’ meetings can be an informative way to evaluate candidates, but not everyone has time to attend them. Any reporting you can provide on which candidates are no-shows, which are disrespectful of their opponents and the process, and which speak well and are likely to serve the public effectively will also be helpful.
Again, thanks!
Thanks!! George