It’s a clean sweep in Comox! In Courtenay, Manno’s your new mayor after vote split
Progressive vote-splitting took its toll again in the Comox Valley. This time for the mayor’s chair in the City of Courtenay. Although the majority of voters did not want Manno Theos at the helm, he nevertheless won the race with 3,870 votes and 44.5 percent of the vote.
Incumbent Bob Wells finished second with 2,595 votes or 29.8 percent. Trish McPhail finished last with 2,185 votes or 25.1 percent. Together, they had 4,780 votes, which is 910 more votes than Theos.
There were 8,650 votes cast for the mayor’s race and 8,698 overall or 38.5 percent of eligible voters. That’s a 12.6 percent increase over 2022’s 25.9 percent.
Theos takes the mayor’s seat after losing a council bid in 2022, after serving 20 years in that capacity. The mayor’s race looked like a match between incumbent Wells and former council member Theos until first-time candidate Trish McPhail threw her hat into the ring on the final filing day, making it a three-way contest.
While the six-member council will retain a progressive majority with Incumbents Wendy Morin and Evan Jolicoeur and newcomers Kelly Matthews and Thomas McDevitt, there will be some other voices around the table this term.
Ex-Vancouver police Dick Clancy received the fourth highest vote total with 2,941 votes or 33.8 percent. And Rosanna Chamberlin claimed the last seat with 2,685 votes or 30.9 percent.
Incumbent David Frisch finished near the bottom of the 19 council candidates with just 17.9 percent of the vote.
“With three incumbents not running, we knew Courtenay Council was going to look very different after election night,” poll-topper Morin told Decafnation. “It’s clear from the numbers that progressive values still dominant Courtenay. The majority of voters endorsed the direction of the outgoing council.
“But the balance is there for those with opposing views. It will be an interesting 4 years.”
COMOX
In Comox, it appears that four newcomers filing at the last minute caught the Old Block majority off guard. Expecting little competition and maybe several acclamations, the Old Block wasn’t prepared for the well-organized machine that boosted Dr. Jonathan Kerr and Jenn Meilleur into office in 2022.
And it resulted in a clean sweep this time.
“This is a historic night for Comox and it is a victory for all Comox residents who have said that they want a Comox Council that listens to them,” Kerr told Decafnation last night. Kerr topped the polls again with 81.3 percent of the vote.
Former Green Party federal candidate Jessica Wegg came next with 69 percent, followed by Jenn Meilleur, Lisa Bourgeois, Neil Ladell and Vivian Chislett.
Incumbent Chris Haslett was the top vote-getter from the Old Block, but he wasn’t close to making the cut. He trailed Chislett by 777 votes. Chislett had 51.8 percent to Haslett’s 34.8 percent. Ken Grant had 32.9 percent, Steve Blacklock had 31.1 percent and Maureen Swift finished last of the Old Block at 30.4 percent.
The total votes cast went up by 703 votes over 2022 and the turnout jumped from 29.2 percent to 36.4 percent this year.
“I am so excited for the Town of Comox and where the next four years will take us,” Wegg told Decafnation. “We can make Comox a fun place for people of all ages.”
It’s clear that Comox residents did not like the process for updating the town’s Official Community Plan and felt their feedback at two overflowing public hearings wasn’t taken seriously. The prospect of six-storey buildings lining Comox Avenue may not have appealed to residents.
Voters were also motivated by several proposed large developments that triggered the formation of neighborhood associations.
“Congrats to all of the Comox residents in their neighbourhoods who knocked on doors, shared information about the election,” Vivian Chislett told Decafnation. “It was democracy in action.”
Ladell agreed. “I really want to thank the community for putting their trust in me. It is the community’s voice that matters, and I am committed to that over the next four years,” he told Decafnation.
“I’m genuinely grateful for the trust and support residents have shown us,” Bourgeois told Decafnation. “One of the best parts of this campaign has been meeting so many people, listening to their concerns and hearing their hopes for Comox. I’m excited about the opportunity to work alongside my fellow councillors, bring fresh perspectives to the table and continue those conversations. There’s a lot of work ahead, but tonight I’m feeling incredibly grateful and optimistic about what’s possible when we work together.”
This morning, Jenn Meilleur added her thoughts. “I’m feeling an enormous sense of gratitude and hope! Throughout this campaign, we met so many people who care deeply about Comox, have wonderful ideas for its future and truly want to be part of building what comes next. I think these results reflect a real appetite for a different kind of local governance that’s more collaborative, open to community participation, and willing to think creatively about our future.”
CUMBERLAND
Incumbents Nick Ward, Troy Therrien and Sean Sullivan were elected along with newcomer Ellian Bell. Incumbent Neil Borecky lost his seat, finishing with 618 votes.
Ward topped the polls with 1,049, followed by Troy Therrien with 936 and Ellian Bell with 848. Sullivan made the cut with 742 by 75 votes over fifth place Kevin Snaden. Ward won his seat in a by-election when former councillor Jesse Ketler stepped down.
Mayor Vickey Brown was unopposed and won by acclamation.
“Many thanks to all of the candidates for putting their name forward. Its so nice to have experienced councillors and another woman,” Mayor Brown told Decafnation. “Thank you Cumberland.”
Of the 3,480 eligible voters in the village, 1,492 cast a ballot, or 42.9 percent. That’s up one full percentage point over the 2022 election.
“Cumberland is a very intelligent community. They showed up and voted in a diverse and very capable and succinct council,” Sullivan told Decafnation. “The future is bright, as it always is in Cumberland.”
ELECTORAL AREA B
After losing by 23 votes in 2022, Arzeena Hamir came back this year to challenge incumbent Richard Hardy and beat him handily 1,156 to 694 votes. Or, 62.5 percent of the vote to Hardy’s 37.5 percent.
“It’s great to be back,” Hamir told Decafnation last night. “I’m so looking forward to ensuring Area B has a strong voice both at the RD table and in working with Comox.”
ELECTORAL AREA C
The race for Electoral Area C was thrown wide-open when 18-year veteran Edwin Grieve decided to retire. That left Ariel Becherer, Gillian Anderson and Normal McPhail to win over Merville and Black Creek voters.
McPhail, a retired RCMP superintendent, won the seat by 86 votes, 1,020 to 934 for second-place finished Ariel Becherer. McPhail had 45.9 percent of the vote, compared to Becherer’s 42 percent. Gillian Anderson finished with 270 votes.
SCHOOL TRUSTEE
The only race for the School District 71 Board of Trustees this year occurred in Courtenay, where incumbent Shannon Aldinger, Kendall Packham and Maria Sanchez sought the two seats. Sanchez ran on the anti-vaxx, anti-SOGI platform.
Aldinger topped the polls at 4,940 and Packham finished well ahead of the challenger with 3,311. Sanchez missed the cut by 902 votes.
PROVINCIAL ADVANCE VOTING LOCATIONS ON OCT. 24
COURTENAY-COMOX
Former Leeward Liquor Store — Fri-Wed Oct 16-21 Courtenay-Comox Native Sons Hall — Fri Oct 16 — Sun-Mon Oct 18-19, –Wed Oct 21 Courtenay-Comox United Mennonite Church Black Creek 2 — Mon-Wed Oct 19-21
MI-ISLAND PACIFIC RIM
Cumberland Cultural Centre — Mon-Tue Oct 19-20
SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTER
The Week: The sun still rises every morning, just a lot later than usual, and other stuff
The Week looks at the time change chaos created by former BC Premier John Horgan’s sketchy poll and asks, “Why?” And then we turn to a candidate who this week announced her candidacy for the 2029 federal election and ask, “Why?” Finally we take a deeper dive into hospital boards with Doug Hillian and throw out some data about data centers
Inaugural meeting: Comox Council considers a six-storey project, Mayor Minions’s address
The Town of Comox held its inaugural council meeting Wednesday night so new councillors could take the oath of office and Mayor Nicole Minions could deliver her State of the Town address. But unlike traditional inaugural meetings, this one required the new council to address a development project approved by the previous council that conflicts with the election mandate opposed to six-storey buildings in the downtown core.
Courtenay City Council majority overrules new Mayor Theos’s appointments
Manno Theos may have won the Courtenay mayor’s office but he lost the first battle with the City Council this week, as four councillors objected to his proposed appointments to the regional district board and other assignments. Instead, the council majority passed their own list of appointments, leaving Theos off the CVRD board.
Mayor Brown gets emotional, says the village inspires her even on the hardest days
Mayor Vickey Brown and four Village Council members were sworn into office Monday night and accepted appointment to various boards and committees. In her inaugural address Brown acknowledged the importance of provincial funding and asked the community to leave the campaign behind and now focus on collaboration and team-building.
The Week: Manno’s speech, buying beds in CR, high five for Johns and the bird for Gunn
‘The Week’ is back — a weekly commentary on whatever comes our way. This week, a demo inaugural speech for new Mayor Manno Theos, how Comox Valley taxpayers are funding new long-term care beds in Campbell River, imagining Josie Osborne as the new BC NDP party leader and a bunch of other stuff.
Will Cole-Hamilton bucks the trend, flips Courtenay Comox riding to NDP
More than four thousand fewer Green Party voters showed up this year and incumbent Conservative MLA Brennan Day lost 787 votes as the NDP won in Courtenay-Comox by about a three percent margin. The ‘blue wave’ was strong across the province, however, taking 64 of the 93 seats in the BC Legislature
THE WEEK: NDP trails BC Conservatives in polls, undecideds will determine outcome
This week: Province-wide polling indicates the NDP have fallen behind BC Conservatives heading into Election Day and that undecided NDP and Green Party voters will decide the outcome in swing ridings like Courtenay-Comox. Also, what should British Columbians think about the Alberta secession referendum? And if you suffer from Long Covid or other chronic diseases, funding cuts to virtual care may affect you
Voting stats show some positive trends in the local government elections
The Comox Valley’s 2026 local government election results show more women sought public office and were elected this year, especially in the Town of Comox. Plus overall voter turnout increased over the last municipal election in 2022. And, we look back to 1949, the year one new council member was born.
Decafnation recommends Will Cole-Hamilton for Courtenay-Comox riding
Will Cole-Hamilton is not just the “greenist” candidate in the Courtenay-Comox riding, he also the best candidate. Decafnation recommends that you vote for him. His Conservative Party opponent’s colleagues are fostering a hard-right Maple-MAGA movement. And, please, don’t vote Green again, you’re just helping the Conservatives.
It’s U-Pick’em time tomorrow, choose carefully from this wild and crazy crop of candidates
The Post War and Boomer Babies forgot to do a bunch of stuff, or just left it undone because they were too scared to raise taxes. So, when the millennials came along in 2018 they started cleaning up the mess. Now the city may fall into the hands of a wild and crazy bunch of newcomers. So let’s talk taxes, debt, pools, water meters and, once again, the Puntledge Triangle.
To me the big question is whether Trish McPhail just didn’t give a damn if Courtenay has a rightwing mayor not much interested in anything other than moneyed interests and his own ego? She wasn’t going to get elected.All her candidacy could do is draw off enough progressive votes to see Mano elected.
Hello George…I typed several sentences of comment in the wrong part of this comment form and found it was not posted. Rather than trying to recreate my earlier comment I will wait until the Federal election on the 17th, and comment again then. I am working full time but turned 80 in June so don’t take on more than I need to.
Always interested in your comments to my Vancouver/First Nations Perspective. Wait until the 17th and then Review and Comment as you wish.
SUKI
George, thanks for your coverage. While I’m not happy with the mayoral results in Courtenay, c’est la guerre.
Thank you for research and analysis. It helped with my choices.
A clear victory for new brooms at first glance. That said, when former mayors endorse the new mayor of Courtenay – man-0-man (absolutely intended!) – you have to wonder whether we have returned to a new “old person’s club”? Will they gather at the Elks Club or Starbucks?
It will be entertaining when newcomers in all jurisdictions face the reality of budgets, tax levies and the inevitable NIMBY-ism opposing development.
Thank you for your service to the defeated and the elected.
Thank you, George for you clear and concise manner of laying out the issues of concern for our communities. Your voice helped us to make change.
Thanks George for getting us through another election with stellar in-depth research and analysis, served up with your unique and entertaining combo of wit and wisdom.
Hi George,
I have to say that you are your panel are very connected to the voting community, with your predictions. Amazing connectivity in Comox and Cumberland- 100 percent!
I,m pleased to see that Courtenay council will have more of a balance. Also the CVRD with the election of Norm McPhail in area C.